Downtier Browning M1918 to BR II

  • Yes
  • No
  • Other
0 voters

Introduction

I mean what can I say? It’s been requested quite a few times…and now’s a good time to request it once more, especially since for Enlisted’s 6th birthday event, they’ve released a virtually identical event BAR. I figured there’s also a pretty strong case for it, since there is now 3 previously BR III LMGs in BR II, most notably the ZB-26 and recently the Type 99 LMG.

Here’s the Analysis for you to read (it is by no means comprehensive, but it’s there for you to look at the individual LMG stats yourself):

Analysis
Browning M1918

  • 12.0 damage
  • 600 rpm
  • 20 round magazine
  • 830m/s muzzle velocity
  • 2.5s reload
  • 39 shot deviation
  • 41 vertical recoil
  • 15 horizontal recoil
  • 75% sprint factor
ZB-26

  • 12.0 damage
  • 600 rpm
  • 20 round magazine
  • 750m/s muzzle velocity
  • 3.2s reload
  • 37 shot deviation
  • 35 vertical recoil
  • 20 horizontal recoil
  • 50% sprint factor
Type 99 LMG

  • 12.0 damage
  • 550 rpm
  • 30 round magazine
  • 710m/s muzzle velocity
  • 3.5s reload
  • 36 shot deviation
  • 36 vertical recoil
  • 21 horizontal recoil
  • 60% sprint factor

As we can see the Browning M1918 has significantly higher sprint speed. It also has a noticeably shorter reload (as compared to the Type 99 LMG). It also has a higher vertical recoil than the 2 other LMGs, but the lowest horizontal recoil. It also has the highest shot deviation. The damage and rpm is pretty on par with the others too, and magazine capacity is low.

Against The Other BR II LMGs

MG 13

  • 12.0 damage
  • 600 rpm
  • 25 round magazine
  • 750m/s muzzle velocity
  • 3.1s reload
  • 38 shot deviation
  • 28 vertical recoil
  • 20 horizontal recoil
  • 50% sprint factor
Type 97 LMG

  • 12.0 damage
  • 550 rpm
  • 20 round magazine
  • 710m/s muzzle velocity
  • 2.8s reload
  • 31 shot deviation
  • 37 vertical recoil
  • 17 horizontal recoil
  • 45% sprint factor
Type 11 LMG

  • 11.2 damage
  • 500 rpm
  • 30 round magazine
  • 730 m/s muzzle velocity
  • 3.8s reload
  • 38 shot deviation
  • 29 vertical recoil
  • 20 horizontal recoil
  • 50% sprint factor
Breda Mod. 30

  • 12.0 damage
  • 480 rpm
  • 20 round magazine
  • 670m/s muzzle velocity
  • 3.2s reload
  • 36 shot deviation
  • 33 vertical recoil
  • 22 horizontal recoil
  • 50% sprint factor
Bren Mk. II

  • 12.0 damage
  • 480 rpm
  • 30 round magazine
  • 760m/s muzzle velocity
  • 2.5s reload
  • 37 shot deviation
  • 35 vertical recoil
  • 20 horizontal recoil
  • 60% sprint factor

Once again, the same story applies. About ballpark damage and RPM (exception being Breda with only 480 rpm and Type 11 LMG with 11.2 damage). Much higher muzzle velocity and sprint factor. The reload is also much quicker than the others (albeit the Bren Mk. II), and vertical recoil is also once again much higher. It is also once again one of the lowest capacity LMGs, even in BR II.

TL;DR

From the comparison of the above LMGs, we’ve discovered that:

  • The Breda is a powerless POS (please buff)

  • The BAR’s damage and RPM is on par for BR II
    (especially taking it’s 20 round mag into consideration).

  • The reload is significantly faster than other LMGs
    (It can be nerfed)

  • The sprint factor is far too fast for BR II
    (it should be nerfed)

  • Shot deviation, muzzle velocity and recoil are ok
    (I would just nerf horizontal recoil and muzzle velocity)

Conclusion

Here is a list of what I believe should be nerfed on the BAR to make it BR II ready:

  • Nerf sprint factor from 75% to 60% (that way it can still be used in its intended role)
  • Nerf ADS speed (if it is faster than the BR III average)
  • Nerf reload from 2.5s to 2.9s (a medium between BR II reloads)
  • Nerf horizontal recoil from 15 to 22 (also the highest horizontal recoil for BR II)
8 Likes

Wasn’t the Type 99 moved to BR2 because it was basically a Japanese Bren gun?

1 Like

I mean technically it’s a better Bren. It has a bayonet and faster RPM, and 60% sprint factor, but kind of struggles on reload.

1 Like

No. You just got your BR2 bar.

Using the event BAR is not an excuse to justify not bringing the Browning M1918 down to BR II. Actually give me a good reason as to why I shouldn’t, or just don’t comment at all.

10 Likes

Just to get the base 1918 BAR to BR2 I would even be fine with the Dev’s nerfing the ROF down to say, 500 base and 550 or 570 maxed. Besides being a backer of dropping the base BAR to BR2, I have also in the past proposed that the Dev’s decrease the horizontal recoil of the MG-13, make the Soviet RPK1943 and Japanese Hotchkiss 1922 tech tree.

1 Like

22 horizontal is horrendous for a BAR. The event one will have half that. All of the Colt’s stats are good except the fire rate. It’s a hundred less comparatively.

It doesn’t really make sense to nerf the sprint factor of the lightest BAR variant in the entire game. Personally I think it would make more sense to drop the A1 or even the A2 down to BR2.

Considering most of the changes from M1918 to A1 to A2 have no affect on gameplay, the main factor that was consistent was the latter variants weighing noticeably more than the original. The main exception would be the magazine guide on the A2.

So why not nerf the sprint speed on the A1 and A2, and then nerf the reload speed on the M1918 and A1. The A1 would get hit with 2 nerfs and be in the position to be dropped to BR2 while the M1918 and A2 would still be good weapons with clear and obvious upsides when compared with one another.

5 Likes

Are you suggesting to bring a2 down to br2? I hope not, the a2 is far superior over the other models. It should definitely stay as is in br3

2 Likes

It just wouldn’t make sense, as they’d have to remove the auto slow, and then what? It’s just another M1918 clone.

I voted other because Yes with nerfs keep the rof nerf the recoil and dispersion to be equal to BR 2 equivalent MGs.

1 Like

Schlawg…

Nerfing velocity is unnessesary and unreasonable - unless you have a source to back things up. .30-60 weapons just has that velocity in-game, same as rifles.

2 Likes

I thought the Springfield’s still had a slower velocity, but I’ll remove it as it is pretty inconsequential anyway. Either way I was just trying to make the BAR as appealing as possible for BR II.

1 Like

Here your answer



Also idk how that guy thinks that the MG-13 and ZB are better than the browning M1918

Because all they need to do is collect their paycheck — they don’t even have to play the game.

2 Likes

yes

There is no reason to have three BAR’s all lumped together in a single battle rating.

And no, adding an event weapon/squad to the game does not fix this issue.

2 Likes

No TT MG with 75% sprint speed should be BR2 thats the thing

1 Like

I and many other people have already gone over this but this is a poor, unimaginative, and unhistoricle solution. The M1918 was actually better than the latter versions because it was much better with run and gun like stuff. In many ways it was the first assault rifle. It would make much more sense for the A2 to go down instead of better yet the Johnson MG. The Johnson MG actually has an incorrect fire rate with its real one being 450RPM. This makes it the perfect option for a US MG at BR2. With that being said however I cannot deny that the current BAR system is flawed. All 3 should have there own pros and cons. Im current working on a suggestion on it actualy.

2 Likes