Downtier Browning M1918 to BR II

Heres a sneak peak at said sugestion
Suggested changes

Name Vert. Recoil Sprint Penalty Movement Dispersion Increase

While Aiming Movement Dispersion Increase

Hip Firing
Browning M1918 40 -20% 15.0 5.0
Browning M1918A1 35 -25% 10.0 10.0
Browning M1918A2 30 -30% 8.0 12.0

The interesting thing about the BAR is that it was originally designed for hipfireing under the walking fire doctrine. Soldiers armed with it even issued kit to help with firing it more accurately from the hip. The A1 were modified for a more LMG role largely losing this functionality along with the special (hip firing) kit not being issued. A2s were (re)designed ground up to be LMGs so they lost this ability

even more, however still being much better at it than most guns due to its underlying foundations. However the later versions also added shoulder plates and were heavier resulting in them being more stable once braced against the shoulder.

As you can see my current problem is that I cant get the table to transfer over for some reason.
You can see the full document here Channel 4 War thunder and Enlisted - Google Documenten (its under “BAR rework”) (I have opened up comments if you want to suggest things)

2 Likes

Well yeah it needs to be nerfed first. Though I think the A1 variant makes the most sense to downrate, since its just the regular 1918 but with added weight, so should be more unwieldy to gun on the run with.

3 Likes

I hate to be the one to break this to you buddy, but the Lahti-Saloranta M/26 exists.

1 Like

Event squads do not count for filling tech tree gaps.

Nah man that’s so trash. Well hopefully Euthy just meams the first variant specifically, not an outright no to any BAR or Johnson even being dropped down.

1 Like

I think Johnson should be put into BR2

1 Like

Yes, just like I said, It makes so much more sense. (with the ROF nerf of course)

1 Like

Ouch…but you are right. When I look back on it I really did do a shit job of a suggestion. That’s what I get for doing it when I’m tired I guess. I never knew that the M1918 was actually better at an assault rifle role than the A1, but I should’ve researched too. Man I really hate my suggestion now.

I usually make more straightforward or less controversial suggestions, and this was my attempt at something more.

I can’t believe I forgot about this MG. Should’ve done it on this instead. But I think someone has in the past and it’s gotten an even more lukewarm reaction than even my suggestion.

2 Likes

Read sir read I said TT there are more high sprint speed Br2 MGs like the RPK 1943 or the Lewis AR and the one you said the lathi but those are or event or BP I said TT because the spam of those MGs would be huge you would see more sealclubbers bullying new players with BARs at Br2 just wait until the people get this new R75 and the complains will start

Nah, its all good man. Im sure there are plenty of other suggestions you have that would be good.

1 Like

I dont consider USA lacking a bar in br2 a tech tree gap… vickers is perfectly fine if you can work around the top load.

WILD take.

A1 maybe but no to the A2 I do think the A2 is where it should be, but the A1 and standard variant are way too high.