There is no 15-round Mkb-series mag, the devs just dropped the ball and gave the real 10-round mag +5 magic bullets. That should be corrected, not further add to the problem.
Again, it’s not “much more accurate”, did you not read that part…?
Are you using the word “controllable” in place of “accurate”…? Stop doing that. There is no issue with a carbine-style weapon being more easily controllable than a full-powered rifle… that is to be expected.
And, again, the M1 Carbine can be accused of almost everything you mentioned, yet that is somehow fine… and the S&W Light Rifle is arguably even worse, because it’s BR I. If a two-tap 30-rounds is such a problem at BR III, where’s the complaint about a two-tap 20-rounder in BR I…?
I do seriously think you’re not adopting a wide enough perspective on the issue… compare the VG 1-5 to other carbine weapons, not the standard BR III semi-auto rifle…
throwing around alotta big words dosent really help getting points across mahaps consider im new to forum posts here so going off on some big worded reditor tirade is not helpful in the slightest
did you not watch the clips most other semis had most the magazine miss while the vg had a dinner plate sized dispersion with no recoil with 30 round mags it is increidibly accurate for something mass produced for conscripted civies
dispersion was not the same m1s was higher giving any rifle man or non assaulter a rifle that can kill an entire squad with body shots while missing shots is not balanced
i did but was kinda distracted by the rather agressive attack on the post and am still looking for functional criticism to remake the post but you wanna have a mild slap fight
from a few searches i do have a rough idea of a historical change that would balance it seems they rarely were given full mags so it wouldn’t be outlandish to artificially cut them back with some recoil and dispersion changes to lower its insanely aggressive hip fire
so before i close this post to redo it as its become horribly of topic and ied like to rebuild it with a fresh start what other ideas would fit please lay them out plainly and in a simple way
Drop the ridiculous fake magazine and fire-selection options, focus on reducing its dispersion, and try to present a coherent, legible, argument (or set of arguments) for why you believe things should be changed, sticking entierly towards objective statistics and avoiding unfounded hyperboly or personal/subjective statements. Everything you say must either backed by solid proof, or be perfectly understood as a personal statement.
And, don’t take things so personally on the forums… this was your trial by fire, now you know you need to back up what you claim - actually try to reason out why your suggestion should be considered.
If you would like to see a model of a well researched, well argued, and well presented topic, then you can look around the forums for inspiration. Considering that you want to make a mixed gameplay/historical adjustment to the VG 1-5, consider looking into @Valkay 's topic on the Kiraly as a good example for how that would look like;
magazine thing is arguable with it just being half loaded a fairly common thing done across the war tho in many cases it was magazine spring life in this things case as a cheap last dich gun half loading could keep it inline with br 3 carbines and represent the strained logistics but yes i do have some better info to work with and thank you
