**The TZ45 as it stands is just a worse clone of the Beretta M38/40 — Buffing the Forgotten Premium Squad**

Preface
The TZ-45 SMG squad has been all but forgotten since its introduction. As a premium (paid) squad, its weapon is comprehensively inferior to free tech-tree weapons of the same Battle Rating — and its soldiers’ starting perk and point distribution are equally underwhelming. This post proposes a fair and restrained buff based on hard data.

One thing should be made clear up front: premium squad presets are not “stronger” by default — they are simply configured according to the developers’ taste. That means the TZ-45 squad, as paid content, currently enjoys no real experience advantage over free squads. That itself is a problem worth addressing.

——————

Problem Analysis

1. Core stat(Ger BR III SMG)

2. Time to Kill (ms)


TTK ZK-383 MP35/I M38A/40 TZ-45
10m 148 160 174 174
10m (no armor) 87 80 87 87
25m 148 160 174 174
50m 148 160 174 174
75m 222 160 261 261
75m (no armor) 148 160 174 174
100m 222 240 261 261

3. Shots to Kill (13.5 HP Target, Rounded Up)

Distance ZK-383 MP35/I M38A/40 TZ-45
10m 3 (2 no armor) 3 (2 no armor) 3 (2 no armor) 3 (2 no armor)
25m 3 3 3 3
50m 3 3 3 3
75m 4 (3 no armor) 3 4 (3 no armor) 4 (3 no armor)
100m 4 4 4 4

4. Dispersion at 50m (30 Rounds, No Recoil Compensation)

cip
aip

Metric ZK-383 MP35/I M38A/40 TZ-45
Max spread radius 46cm 56cm 56cm 48cm
R90 624cm 846cm 769cm :x: 1019cm
Vertical climb +361cm +452cm +390cm :x: +609cm
Ring target score 3.2 2.4 2.9 :x: 1.9
Misses 12 14 13 :x: 18

5. Dispersion at 50m (Recoil Compensated, Average of 6 Tests)

Metric ZK-383 MP35/I M38A/40 TZ-45
Overall hit rate 77% 40% 43% 43%
Head/neck hit rate 7% 3% 3% 3%
Body hit rate 63% 53% 43% 37%
Limb hit rate 7% 3% 13% 3%
Complete misses 5 16 10 13

The TZ-45 and M38A/40 share identical damage, rate of fire, magazine size, and TTK — the TZ-45 is a reskin of the Beretta;
Yet the TZ-45 is dead last in recoil (V/H 16/7), recoil control (50%), and vertical/horizontal recoil (31/13);

Its only apparent advantage (max spread radius 48cm) is cancelled out by its worse R90 (1019cm) and higher miss count (18);

Its ring-target score of 1.9 is the lowest of the four guns— in practice, it is comprehensively less accurate than its free, same-source counterpart.

As a paid weapon, the TZ-45 has no reason to exist: at BR III there are three stronger free SMGs — ZK-383, MP35/I, and Beretta M38A/40.

——————

The Proposal

Part 1: Recoil Sync (Fairness Fix)

Stat Current Proposed
Recoil V/H 16/7 10/3 (sync with M38A/40)
Recoil control 50% 60% (sync with M38A/40)

Rationale: the TZ-45 and M38A/40 use the same 40-round magazine, the same 9×19mm ammunition, and share the same design lineage — their damage and rate of fire are identical. Yet the recoil differs by nearly a factor of two. This gap has no historical basis and looks more like a data-entry oversight. Syncing the recoil does not change its “reskin” identity — it simply makes it no longer strictly worse.

Part 2: Better fire rate

form wikipedia
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6aoueQwzX4c 2
Based on the fire rate in the video, it can be roughly calculated as:
40 rounds in 3.2s.
40 ÷ 3.2 = 12.5 r/s
12.5 × 60 = 750 RPM
(a bit lower if you count the 39 intervals between rounds, but 750 is the standard estimate)
That lands almost exactly in the 750–800 RPM range cited by IMFDB and ww2db — and well above the 690 RPM the TZ-45 currently has in-game. Combined with the fact that the TZ-45 shares its damage and magazine with the Beretta M38A/40, this means tz-45 is a reskin that’s slowed down on top of having worse recoil.
So I think buffing the fire rate to 690–750(Fully maxed) is reasonable.
even higher than 750

——————

POLL

Which TZ-45 buff option do you support?
  • Part I + Part II
  • Only Part I
  • Only Part II
  • Reject the proposal, leave it as is
0 voters

——————

And all weapon data in this post comes from the community data site
Enlisted Pro https://enlisted-pro.vercel.app/
dv

9 Likes

The fire rate of TZ-45 is higher than 600 rpm, just listen in on this and you can clearly hear it being in the ~750-800 round per minute range

So the fire rate buff of part II is a necessary correction anyway.

8 Likes

I forgot to disable the public vote…

i forgot to rig the vote

3 Likes

Technically, no it doesn’t. You can see in the stats that the MAB 38 has 430m/s muzzle velocity, while the TZ-45 has 400m/s. That means the MAB 38 uses 9x19mm M38 ammo while the TZ-45 uses 9x19 Parabellum ammo. The TZ-45 should be rechambered to M38 ammo so it gets faster muzzle velocity and rof and higher damage.

2 Likes

Forgot? Polls should always be public.

Gets less votes though.

4 Likes

Sure, the vote count would be a lot lower, but getting people to openly express their opinions isn’t the same as getting more people to express their honest opinions :confused:

1 Like

Nice addition, yeah that my mistake.

No no please dont touch the last useful stuff for Germans, i dont trust you or the devs… Its a top BR3 state right now

You look like those guys:

5 Likes

If you don’t mind, I can explain it again for you. :slightly_smiling_face:

I have taken all existing BR III submachine guns into consideration and found one tiny balance issue with the fire rate increase:

Submachine Guns Damage Reload Timings (s) Statcard Recoil Effective Recoil Moving Spread Increase
Weapon Name Obtained BR 10m 100m Velocity Magazine Reload Alt Reload Rate of Fire Vertical Horizontal Recoil Control Vertical Horizontal Dispersion While Aiming Hipfiring Visual Recoil Recoil Dir ADS Speed Recoil Offset Sprint Factor Weight Additional Info
TZ-45 with buff Premium III 6.8 4.0 400 40 2.3 1.89 860 26 7 0.4 10 3 0.55 0.0 15.0 1.4 0.1 0.8 0.3 100% 3.2 40/120
Type 2a SMG 38000 RP III 6.8 3.9 350 30 2.3 - 860 9 9 0.4 4 4 0.64 0.0 10.0 1.0 0.4 0.9 - 100% 3.4 30/120
Beretta M38A 40 118000 RP III 6.8 4.0 430 40 2.6 2.2 690 26 7 0.4 10 3 0.65 0.0 15.0 1.6 0.4 0.8 0.3 100% 5.2 40/120
Kiraly 39M 120000 RP IV 7.9 4.6 445 40 2.0 1.4 870 32 12 0.4 13 5 0.70 0.0 15.0 1.6 0.5 0.8 0.3 100% 4.4 40/120

My main concern is that the TZ-45, with 750 rpm base fire (would mean 860 max upgraded) would be way too strong with its current stats. Unless we make an unusual exception and make the max upgraded fire rate 750 rpm (which would put the default at 650 rpm) at which point it would still be slightly cracked.

The most comparable BR III guns are:

  • Type 2a SMG, which would be out shined in every category. I would be fine with making TZ-45 slightly stronger, to justify its price, but giving both guns the same fire rate without giving TZ-45 a downside for its larger magazine would be straight up heavy pay to win.
  • There would be no reason to use Beretta M38A 40 with Axis either
  • The main issue: TZ-45 even with its buffs would still not be good enough for BR IV

In my opinion, the TZ-45 is buff is fair, but it should get some nerfs to balance it.
compared to the Type 2a SMG, the TZ-45 gets 1.35x more magazine capacity, so increasing the reload with 1.35 would be fair, as well as lowering the dispersion to 0.70 (about average for SMGs)

Submachine Guns Damage Reload Timings (s) Statcard Recoil Effective Recoil Moving Spread Increase
Weapon Name Obtained BR 10m 100m Velocity Magazine Reload Alt Reload Rate of Fire Vertical Horizontal Recoil Control Vertical Horizontal Dispersion While Aiming Hipfiring Visual Recoil Recoil Dir ADS Speed Recoil Offset Sprint Factor Weight Additional Info
balanced TZ-45 Premium III 6.8 4.0 400 40 3.2 2.8 860 26 7 0.4 10 3 0.70 0.0 15.0 1.4 0.1 0.8 0.3 100% 3.2 40/120
Type 2a SMG 38000 RP III 6.8 3.9 350 30 2.3 - 860 9 9 0.4 4 4 0.64 0.0 10.0 1.0 0.4 0.9 - 100% 3.4 30/120
Beretta M38A 40 118000 RP III 6.8 4.0 430 40 2.6 2.2 690 26 7 0.4 10 3 0.65 0.0 15.0 1.6 0.4 0.8 0.3 100% 5.2 40/120
Kiraly 39M 120000 RP IV 7.9 4.6 445 40 2.0 1.4 870 32 12 0.4 13 5 0.70 0.0 15.0 1.6 0.5 0.8 0.3 100% 4.4 40/120

Having a larger magazine in return for longer reload is still the better deal IMO, but a justified downside for a premium gun.

2 Likes

Yes, a singular TZ-45 squad makes 3x assaulter squads of m38 40 irrelevant… did you think before typing that? A single premium squad doesn’t make a weapon irrelevant.

2 Likes

Just a detail, velocity should be 430m/s since it would shoot 9mm M38 bullets like the MAB 38
Captura de pantalla (126)

1 Like

I also have a squad worth of Mp41(r) and another batch of Mkb42(H) 15s…
I also use flamethrowers, machine gun squads and other squads, not just 3x assaulters.
But, sure one squad is not a problem, but when premium squad consistently perform better than its a problem.

sure we could make it happen, but in-game the weapon comes with a German squad (stupid I know) I would say it make sense that they get standard German 9mm instead of Italian M38 bullets.

Right, my whole point was that the maxed-out fire rate should be around 750. Guess I didn’t spell that out clearly enough in the post. :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

750 is still a tiny bit cracked, but doesnt need a huge rebalance.

I know I know, I was just sayin’, it was compatible with both German and Italian ammo, and had higher RoF when shooting Italian ammo because it was loaded with more gunpowder or smth

I think you might be mistaken there — more gunpowder affects muzzle velocity more than it does fire rate.

Agreed. The fire rate was only the second part of my suggestion, :slightly_smiling_face: and it was just a conclusion drawn from the wiki, other sources, and videos — in-game you’re free to do whatever you like. But the recoil definitely needs work, because this gun is so bad that the recoil completely cancels out its dispersion. It’s not an exaggeration to say it’s already the worst in its class among BR III SMGs.