Slakrrrrrr's Semi-Automatic Rebalance (Progressive Damage Increase Relative To BR)

Should Semi-Automatic Rifle Damage Be Adjusted To This New Damage Profile?
  • Yes
  • No (Please provide feedback!)
0 voters

The intention of this buff is to do the following things:

  • Make semi-automatic rifles more balanced compared to other weapons of the same battle rating (primarily SMGs and MGs) by increasing damage thresholds for shin and hip shots, as well as at range (which is why bolt-action rifles deal the damage they do at BR 1 and BR 2).
  • Make semi-automatics at BR 4 compared to BR 5 select-fire rifles more balanced and effective, improving BR 4 playability.
  • Create the potential for BR 5 semi-automatics to be added (as an alternative to select-fire rifles).

Semi-Auto Damage Thresholds

Soldier Damage Model

Effective Hitpoints

Essentially, this takes the logic of how bolt-action rifles and semi-automatics at BR 2 compare at BR 2, and extrapolate that relationship to hypothetical semi-automatic rifles and select-fire rifles at BR 5. From there, semi-automatics gain relative increases in damage (with incremental increases in one-shot thresholds to body parts and range) with each battle rating, until they have similar damage strength to high-power bolt-action rifles at BR 5.

The following thresholds are provided to the weapons with the following battle ratings:

BR 3:

  • Soldiers with vitality and body armor can be one-shot at long range (21m for 15.3 damage rifles)
  • Soldiers without vitality can be one-shot from the hip (16.7 damage threshold)
  • Depending on other stats: the range at which a non-vitality soldier can be one-shot depends on damage (17 damage = close range, 19 damage = medium range)

BR 3 rifles would be rebalanced to deal 17-19 damage, depending on balancing from other stats. Gewehr 41 would deal higher damage, SVT-38 would deal lower damage, for example.

BR 4:

  • Soldiers with vitality can be one-shot in the hip (22.5 damage threshold)
  • Soldiers without vitality can be one-shot in the shin (22.2 damage threshold)
  • the damage thresholds of BR 3 rifles can be surpassed at long range.
  • Depending on other stats: the range at which the 22.2 and 22.5 damage thresholds are surpassed (22.2 damage = point blank, 24 damage = medium range)

BR 4 rifles would be rebalanced to deal 22 to 24 damage, depending on balancing from other stats such as magazine capacity and rate of fire. SVT-40 would deal higher damage, SLR 1944 would deal lower damage, for example.

BR 5 (Hypothetical):

  • Previous thresholds are all surpassable at long range.
  • BR 5 semi-automatics would deal between 25.4 (Lee-Enfield, Kar 98K) and 27.9 (Winchester M1895) damage.

Hypothetical BR 5 semi-automatic rifles could deal similar damage to bolt-action rifles. Since they do not have the same cyclic rates and full-auto firing of select-fire rifles of the same battle rating, these weapons can have more damage thresholds they defeat to compensate. And of course, bolt-action rifles fire the same full-power cartridges as other semi-automatic rifles (Soviet 7.62x54mmR, American .30-06, German 7.92x57mm, Japanese 7.7mm etc), so there’s no real reason to not consider these damage increases in this context. Damage is a balance stat, after all.

Ultimately, this makes semi-automatics more reliable and forgiving in terms of one-shots at higher battle ratings. In addition, this means a 22-24 damage semi-automatic at BR 4 is far closer in strength (while not surpassing it) to a BR 5 select-fire. Until a -0/+0 matchmaker is implemented, this would make BR 4 far more enjoyable and playable in an uptier. And of course, BR 5 semi-automatic rifles with this damage profile not only provide variety for rifleman soldiers, but these weapons would be easier to use than select-fires, meaning a player with low or average skill can perform better at BR 5 with these weapons.

I’m looking forward to your thoughts and constructive feedback!

5 Likes

Some visualizers to help understand the thresholds affected generally by each battle rating:

BR 2 Thresholds
BR 3 Thresholds
BR 4 Thresholds

1 Like

That’s a nope for me
Same ammo, same weapon type but different damage just because the BR?
That is so weird

5 Likes

So do bolt-actions and semi-automatics at BR 2. Is that weird?

Winchester M1895
Fedorov M1912 02

1 Like

Bolt rifle would be OHK guaranty, so i’ll choose them, not the 5 round semi that can only kill 2~3 each clip

So you would pick a semi-automatic at BR 5 over a select-fire. That’s great, since it would increase the variety of combat in BR 5!

1 Like

No they have same damage, and we don’t even have a BR 5 semi now

But you read the post, right?

A semi-automatic at BR 5 would deal between 25.4 and 27.9 damage in this suggestion. Damage is a balance stat after all, otherwise bolt-action rifles and semi-auto rifles firing the same cartridge would deal the same damage.

Even a BR 4 semi-auto would be much more consistent per bullet than a select-fire, meaning BR 4 would become more popular.

I’ll say just nerf recoil control of SF even more

1 Like

That means even fewer people would use them. Most “competitive” players have recently changed from the AVS-36 20 to AVT-40 20 since they can’t handle it with the new recoil. But there are some people (myself included) that can still use the best weapon, meaning they can perform that much greater than the average player.

Most of the people that want select-fires nerfed are the ones that would suffer the most from it, since they are just pushing for more skill gap. But all things considered, this post is about buffing semi-automatics, not nerfing select-fires.

Stronger semi-automatics means the average player would perform better at higher battle ratings using them, and you would see fewer select-fires as a result of their addition as well.

Yes I still use AVS3620 and fedrov25 full auto within 100m :wave: :grinning:
That’s why I think recoil nerf is not enough

So why we need to buff semi rifle? why we really need BRV semi
I think big recoil SF is fine in BRV, they’re just some large mag semi rifle with “fun mode” in close range, that already make BRIV semi playable

You say you use the AVS/Fedorov, but all I see if you cycling vehicles when I look at your rollcall. You have not even used those guns enough to know anything about it. So stop lying and saying things you have no knowledge on.

4 Likes

I’ve been thinking for quite a while about semi-auto rifles. On the one hand, I think the game generally does a good job with its current approach to balance - most weapons are placed logically in BRs based on real-world qualities that affect their performance.

Calibre (which generally determines damage and velocity), magazine capacity, reloading method (single bullets, clips, or full magazine reloads), and other mechanical attributes lay the groundwork for what a weapon is supposed to be. After all, there’s only so much you can do with, say, a +70-round 9mm SMG (it would have to be extraordinarily nerfed to fit into BR III, let alone BR IV).

I much prefer that approach to arbitrarily increasing a weapon’s damage just because it happens to be a higher BR. If it needs buffs (or nerfs) to be viable somewhere, it’s obviously not meant to be there.


Something I’ve been toying with, however, is a modest damage increase for semi-auto rifles - around 1–2 points across the board (perhaps excluding SF rifles; I’m not sure yet). This would make them much more satisfying to use whilst still leaving room for BAs to compete at lower BRs. I’d probably extend the damage increase to assault rifles as well, for good measure.

Another idea, which I personally prefer but which would be more controversial, is to rebalance all rifles around the Kretz P13: standard BA damage levels for everyone, but a reduced RoF so they’re no longer something you can simply mag-dump (at least not while firing from the shoulder). I think the P13 is an awesome rifle, and I’d love a Garand that functioned like it as well. What I’d love even more is if it were the standard for rifles across the board. Still, that’s a massive leap from where we are now.

The latter would also finally solve the disparity between BA and semi-auto damage. It’s always struck me as an understandable, but unsatisfying, balance compromise. The first solution would help, but sadly wouldn’t resolve it entirely.

Anyway, those are my thoughts on the subject. I just dislike the idea that a weapon magically hits harder because of its BR or fire selector. It cheapens the weapon’s inherent qualities, then opens up the whole debate over what weapon ‘deserves’ to be in which BR. Faction mains would have plenty of opinions on that, and frankly, I don’t think it’s a debate even worth entertaining.

1 Like

Beacuse that would make BR4 better to play? We dont need BR5 semi-auto, we need to make BR4 semi-auto competitive when it gets uptiered so a BR4 player actually has a better chanse of succeeding.

2 Likes

I think weapons are relatively obvious in terms of which BR they should be, though having a spectrum of options sometimes depending on stats can be a good thing (as an example, a 20 round semi auto could be BR 4 or BR 5). I think that flexibility is important for a game like Enlisted.

But aside from that, I think your thoughts are nuanced and considerate. I would love to see you create a breakdown of the damage parity concept, showcasing how it could be implemented and the problems it would solve in the future!

1 Like

I don’t understand this post can somebody summarize it?
Does he suggest increase semi-auto gun damage and move them to higher br?
Or just only buff semi-auto rifle damage without moving them?

Bro, no one can use this can gun accurately at 100m full auto.

I do not want scaling damage with each battle rating. Br3 is perfectly fine as it sits. Only br4 should get a buff to semi damage and probably not above 20

1 Like


17% vehicle spawn rate, and you tell me i’m cycling vehicles?
I’ve played a few US BR3 match these days, and this is what you’ll found, not much vehicles kills




I play all kind of things in game, any faction, niche BRIV, combined arms. Didn’t stick on BRV SF rifleman squad does not mean I don’t know them.