not a stug
what would you want more heat or a functioning mg
1 Like
It can handle all br2 enemy tanks just fine with heat. Not being able to handle shermans well (even though they only have 80mm worth of frontal armor) isn’t really an argument as they are a higher tier tank. Shermans can’t handle panthers/tigers.
I wouldn’t care if it got a mg in br1.
1 Like
it historically was a threat to them and shermans have a massive slope to em so that deflects also shermans can hit the panthers mantlet and shot trap it or the turret cheeks
this version got a breda mod 30 but it was ditched because they jammed constantly
1 Like
see my thread
most us tanks are generalist doing everything but nothing well the m41 just kills tanks
Which is why it’s okay in br1 now (even though it’s AP round can currently kill infantry if it needs to), adding a bunch of heat (and sure it can even get a MG) in my opinion should be br2 just like the one premmy br2 stug which doesn’t have a mg either)
not opposed to that ive stated nothing agianst rasing its br to 2 i feel it should be there as the m14 does the br 1 roll quite well
1 Like
You kind of did though. Kreig said br2 in the beginning and you argued against it.
no?
Thats how it came off to me. That you were listing off reasons to why it shouldn’t be uptiered to br2, like saying it can’t handle br3 tanks.
Regardless, no argument here if it’s br2. I don’t care if it gets HE even there.
He would be un necessary if you change ur vote while I fix the suggestion to mention raising it to be 2 tho low key I thought it was br 2 already
1 Like
me too
br2 mg, heat, apcb, smoke
1 Like
mg bit added with suggestion to raise it to br 2 i guess cause my crew have bertta 1818s and the commander a fnab i tricked myself into thinking it was br 2 already
1 Like
yeah heat at br1 is a bit much, it only works at br1 because of no he at all. either we need to buff it to br2 or keep it as is.
1 Like
You recieved my vote now
1 Like
A couple of corrections…
It’s the M41 75/32*. There is no M41 75/18 in game, only in War Thunder.
Use War Thunder for shell stats, because Enlisted does not make its own tank shells - the devs import ones from WT (just like the tanks themselves):
If the M41 75/32 got its HEAT shell, it would naturally also get uptiered to BR II.
It would be comparable at that point to the M8 Scott, except it trades the HMG for a enclosed top and a (marginally) stronger HE capability from the HEAT (M8 still has dedicated HE shells which are marginally better). Armour is comparable (though the M8 is more vulnerable to overpreassure because of its open-topped turret). M8 also benefits from a rotating turret.
Overall, they’d be fairly equal, with the difference being you prefer the weakness of a open-topped turret in exchange for having it rotate…
9 smoke seems excessive… make it 7, so; 18/18/7.
Personally, I think Semovente should still get the HEAT shell and get uptiered to BR II. Italy currently has no BR II tech tree tanks (still waiting for the P40), giving them their own M8 Scott equivelant would be more than fair.
We still need a Italian tanker squad to play them with… which remains a pre-merge privilege.
4 Likes
i voted the earlier one as its more appropriate with this being an earlier version but if they must copy the more effective shell it wouldnt be that bad
lol… so because you are mad they rightfully uptiered Sherman 105 you are irrationally disagreeing with something completely unrelated?
Checks out.
1 Like
It gets one shot by everything in br3. It’s not a br4 tank, neither is the tiger h1. German players are crybabies.
1 Like