**Buffing the Forgotten Premium Squad — The TZ-45 SMG Squad**

Preface

The TZ-45 SMG squad has been all but forgotten since its introduction. As a premium (paid) squad, its weapon is comprehensively inferior to free tech-tree weapons of the same Battle Rating — and its soldiers’ starting perk and point distribution are equally underwhelming. This post proposes a fair and restrained buff based on hard data.

One thing should be made clear up front: premium squad presets are not “stronger” by default — they are simply configured according to the developers’ taste. That means the TZ-45 squad, as paid content, currently enjoys no real experience advantage over free squads. That itself is a problem worth addressing.

——————

Problem Analysis

Core stat(Ger BR III SMG)

Stat ZK-383 (Tech Tree) MP35/I (Tech Tree) Beretta M38A/40 (Tech Tree) TZ-45 (Premium)
Ammunition 9mm 9mm 9mm 9mm (Beretta M38 magazine)
Muzzle velocity 400 m/s 400 m/s 430 m/s 400 m/s
Magazine 30 rds 32 rds 40 rds 40 rds
Damage 10m 6.8 7.2 6.8 6.8
Damage 100m 4.0 4.2 4.0 4.0
Damage 150m 3.4 3.6 3.4 3.4
Damage 200m 3.2 3.4 3.2 3.2
Damage 300m 3.0 3.2 3.0 3.0
Rate of fire 810 RPM 750 RPM 690 RPM 690 RPM
Recoil V/H 9/4 12/3 10/3 16/7
Recoil control 60% 60% 60% 50%
Vertical recoil 23 28 26 31
Horizontal recoil 9 8 7 13

2. Time to Kill (ms)

TTK ZK-383 MP35/I M38A/40 TZ-45
10m 148 160 174 174
10m (no armor) 87 80 87 87
25m 148 160 174 174
50m 148 160 174 174
75m 222 160 261 261
75m (no armor) 148 160 174 174
100m 222 240 261 261

3. Shots to Kill (13.5 HP Target, Rounded Up)

Distance ZK-383 MP35/I M38A/40 TZ-45
10m 3 (2 no armor) 3 (2 no armor) 3 (2 no armor) 3 (2 no armor)
25m 3 3 3 3
50m 3 3 3 3
75m 4 (3 no armor) 3 4 (3 no armor) 4 (3 no armor)
100m 4 4 4 4

4. Dispersion at 50m (30 Rounds, No Recoil Compensation)

Metric ZK-383 MP35/I M38A/40 TZ-45
Max spread radius 46cm 56cm 56cm 48cm
R90 624cm 846cm 769cm 1019cm
Vertical climb +361cm +452cm +390cm +609cm
Ring target score 3.2 2.4 2.9 1.9
Misses 12 14 13 18

5. Dispersion at 50m (Recoil Compensated, Average of 6 Tests)

Metric ZK-383 MP35/I M38A/40 TZ-45
Overall hit rate 77% 40% 43% 43%
Head/neck hit rate 7% 3% 3% 3%
Body hit rate 63% 53% 43% 37%
Limb hit rate 7% 3% 13% 3%
Complete misses 5 16 10 13

The TZ-45 and M38A/40 share identical damage, rate of fire, magazine size, and TTK — the TZ-45 is a reskin of the Beretta;
Yet the TZ-45 is dead last in recoil (V/H 16/7), recoil control (50%), and vertical/horizontal recoil (31/13);
Its only apparent advantage (max spread radius 48cm) is cancelled out by its worse R90 (1019cm) and higher miss count (18);
Its ring-target score of 1.9 is the lowest of the four guns— in practice, it is comprehensively less accurate than its free, same-source counterpart.

As a paid weapon, the TZ-45 has no reason to exist: at BR III there are three stronger free SMGs — ZK-383, MP35/I, and Beretta M38A/40.

Squad Perks

A Useless Starting Perk + Skewed Point Distribution

  • Starting perk: currently “Medkit healing +100%” (one medkit = 2x healing). This perk has almost no practical value — a medkit already covers normal healing needs
  • Point distribution: currently 16/16/25 — only 16 red points, not enough to take the otherVitality perk (the extra HP for a 13.5-health target is critical at TTK thresholds. it will be cost 16 point).

There is already a precedent: the StG 45(M) squad had its points changed from 13/14/30 to 16/19/22

History

——————

The Proposal

Part 1: Recoil Sync

Stat Current Proposed
Recoil V/H 16/7 10/3 (sync with M38A/40)
Recoil control 50% 60% (sync with M38A/40)

Rationale: the TZ-45 and M38A/40 use the same 40-round magazine, the same 9×19mm ammunition, and share the same design lineage — their damage and rate of fire are identical. Yet the recoil differs by nearly a factor of two. This gap has no historical basis and looks more like a data-entry oversight.

Part 2: Squad Perk Rework

Item Current Proposed
Point distribution 16/16/25 18/19/20

On point distribution:

  • Red points 16 → 18: enough for the Vitality perk while leaving room for other weapon perks;
  • Yellow points 16 → 19: strengthens stamina and survival perks;
  • Green points 25 → 20: frees up points for a balanced “weapon / survival / mobility” spread.

This 18/19/20 layout differs from the community’s earlier 16/19/22 suggestion — it keeps all three dimensions viable and gives the TZ-45 squad its own identity.

——————

Poll

Which TZ-45 buff option do you support?
  • I support this proposal (recoil sync to M38A/40 + perk point rework)
  • Only rework the perk point distribution
  • Only sync the weapon recoil stats
  • Full buff (I have a more thorough idea)
  • I don’t support any of these
0 voters

——————

The forums seem to be bugged — can’t upload anything, not even images.
And all weapon data in this post comes from the community data site
Enlisted Pro (https://enlisted-pro.vercel.app/
Thanks to Deus_Vult for the resource.

3 Likes

Seems fair the recoil is worse for no reason and perk points being are a bit stingy for a BR 3 squad, I don’t own the squad but thanks to your breakdown I can see how it stacks up.
In regards to the forum png didn’t work for me and jpg, are you saying all image types aren’t working now if so that’s pretty atrocious. At any rate they know and acknowledge that some image types weren’t uploading which is good hopefully it’s sorted soon.

3 Likes

I think the TZ-45 itself should be buffed more. It has 690 RoF in enlisted which is quite a conservative value considering that this gun had between 600 - 800 RoF IRL apparently, according to the Forgotten Weapons. I propose the TZ-45 gets 60 % recoil modifer plus 800 RoF, this should make this gun viable on BR 3.

6 Likes

I agree. Only in this way will I buy it.

2 Likes

Same here.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6aoueQwzX4c

The things one can find by just following links on wikipedia…
Anyone care to calculate RPM here?

1 Like

40 rounds in 3.2s.
40 ÷ 3.2 = 12.5 r/s
12.5 × 60 = 750 RPM

(a bit lower if you count the 39 intervals between rounds, but 750 is the standard estimate)
That lands almost exactly in the 750–800 RPM range cited by IMFDB and ww2db — and well above the 690 RPM the TZ-45 currently has in-game. Combined with the fact that the TZ-45 shares its damage and magazine with the Beretta M38A/40, this means tz-45 is a reskin that’s slowed down on top of having worse recoil.

Thanks for sharing this

1 Like

Just to add another point here but technically the TZ-45 could use both the German regular 9x19 parabellum and the more poweful Italian 9x19 M38 exclussive for the MAB 38 (which is the reason why it has higher muzzle velocity, but strangely the same damage as regular 9x19 SMGs). It could be rechambered for the M38 cartridge and given more damage too, it has a historic base (except that the TZ-45 with the Italian RSl were the ones that loaded their weapons with M38 bullets, while the Germans used their regular available ammo)

2 Likes

Yesterday I bought this squad. The weapon has terrible recoil :skull:

1 Like

Picked this squad up recently as well. If you know German guns, the rate of fire feels fine — the real issue is the spread at long range, which is worse than the Beretta M38. Probably the easiest way to keep it from being P2W is just to adjust the dispersion…

1 Like

If you really want this gun to get buff, you should find some historical sources as evidence and propose buff its fire rate to 700 RPM (810 RPM at max star). Specific suggestions are usually more likely to be taken on board.

Fair point, I’ll take this down and post a better version.

First and foremost, you need to improve the recoil, not the rate of fire.

I have looked into some sources and the only source I found claiming 800 rpm was the Military Factory which is about as strong as a wikipedia page (which also claims 800 rpm by the way).

A stronger claim would be measuring the fire rate on the video: (just by the sound, I can hear that its well over 600 rpm).

Sorry, I need to delete this thread first so I can post an updated version. Thanks for your reply.

Lokalhero

You can have Codex calculate the rate of fire from the audio track. As for the fire rate real world weapons roughly correspond to the 0-star fire rate in game (MP40 has 630 RPM).

You’re just making a Beretta M38 replica more like an actual Beretta M38.