Suggestion, heavy AA guns

Right now, the current AA guns are almost useless against anything but the biplanes,so let’s have high caliber AA guns.it would function like a tank cannon, but fixed, and able to take on planes, finally letting you take out that P47 spammer. You could add the flak 88 for the Germans, the 90MM M1 AA gun for western allies, and the m1939 85MM (52-K)gun for the soviets.it should also be able to elevate to ground targets, as this was a historical thing flak cannons could do, and would give it a use after destroying the planes,but no, balance. If you don’t have this for the heavy AA guns, at least let the normal ones elevate to where they should be able to. This fortification would use up most of your engeneers resources though, only letting you build a rally point or some sandbags, no AT cannons or MGs. This would make it possible to actually do anything against planes like the P-47 continually dropping stupidly broken rockets and bombs on your head and do more than scratch the paint on it.

6 Likes

I wonder how do you want to use 88mm vs P-47. (Without magic and witchcraft.)

“Big gun goes boom” is not an answer to all problems (but for most).

2 Likes

HE-TF shells

they… “work” in war thunder on the VFW ( VFW - War Thunder Wiki ) has a 88 flak with proxy shells that theoretically explode in proximity of airplanes and damage components / “hull”/ structures etc.

which, if you get or shoot in time, chances are, he won’t survive or fly for very long.

but… less than ideal for the majority of people.

it could be fun though.

couldn’t resist :smirk: :relieved:;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_RCtDnfYPGo
such a good song.

2 Likes

88 doesn’t have proxy, it has timed fuze (at least the “regular” version). And from I saw, they are shit in WT.

(I’ll see the vid later.)


To be clear, I’m not against adding 88 (though not as engineers buildable). I just argue that idea of “I’m harrased by a fighter-bomber so let’s add big guns” is simply put stupid. Just like “I’m harased by a sniper so lets add an SMG”. Wrong tool for the job.

4 Likes

yeah. fuzes*

and now that i think about it, a similar varient ( which we could get instead. as somewhat more historical )

would be the:

flak truck ( https://wiki.warthunder.com/8,8_cm_Flak_37_Sfl. )

with L.45s fuzes

800px-GarageImage_8,8_cm_Flak_37_Sfl.

1 Like

yes, adding just because x or y killed me hence i need Z, i agree. it’s a dumb reason.

but the tool is not wrong for that job either, since the flaks were initially invented for AA purposes :smirk:

2 Likes

:+1:

Against bomber formations. Not fighter planes.

2 Likes

" iT’s sTiLl aA pUrpoSeS !1! "

1 Like

I don’t think AA cannons would be very useful due to their slowness of turn, they were designed to destroy bombers at high altitudes at the end of the day, instead of those guns what if we give each nation the late-war AA weapons they had, Germany can receive back its quad 20mm Flak 38, US can have the Quad .50 cal M2, Japan can have the Type 96 25mm and URSS can receive the Maxim Quad M4, but all of this will be pointless without improving the damage of the projectiles and removing the stupid overheating mechanic, AA is not bad but overheating is stupid and the damage is underwhelming(specially the 20mm)

4 Likes

I really completely do not understand calling the current AA useless.
Every time I construct this cannon I knock down 2 planes if I don’t get killed by a tank or a fast rush.
Seriously, the guy in the plane doesn’t even have the option to repair himself outside the Pacific, one fart and you have no wing, engine or just SMG can put you on fire…
One burst and the plane is gone, plus aim assist… of course, if you don’t shoot it like a mentally ill person giving everyone information about where you are before the plane strafes.
I have a feeling that for some SAM systems would still be not enough…

I will say that current AA guns are not useless. I’ve certainly shot down some planes before. Of coarse we shouldn’t look at it that unless you’re one shotting them out of the sky they’re bad

But I will say I do think we should have Heavy AA guns as well. I have suggested Heavy AA guns that can also act as AT guns as well just like in real life

The biggest problem with the 20 mm AA is that some planes just tank way more shots than othere planes. Some planes explode the moment they get hit and a diffrent plane can tank an entire mag worth of AA and still dont die.

My guess is that some planes have bugged dmg models and can keep tanking more rounds causing people to call AA useless and othere planes with a less tanky damage model die causing othere people to flock to defend the current AA and their viability.

1 Like

The current AA is a joke compared to the old Quad 20mm, those are real AA and not peashooter

1 Like

well the P47 can take quite a few hits with the normal one,but this will allow you to destroy it in one hit,so this problem would likely be an answer for “Big gun goes boom”

88mm guns were not invented to take on aircraft flying at <1000m altitude. They’d never get to hit one - they can’t traverse fast enough, and htey can’t fire fast enough, and their time fuzes don’t have a short enough setting - even at “zero” ther is a 2 second delay before the round will explode, which means a minimum range of about 1600 mdters - see section 65(b) -

https://www.lonesentry.com/manuals/88mm-antiaircraft-gun/ammunition-german-88-mm-aa-gun.html

20mm and other “light” FLAK were invented for that. :face_with_monocle:

People who can’t shoot down a/c with the existing 20mm lack skill.

1 Like

If you manage to hit it.
And unless he will fly in a straight line, youhave a very small chance to succeed imo.

I feel like large caliber “AA” guns will be slightly more useful in this game as anti-tank guns instead lol

1 Like

true,most AT guns are just not worth building unless you are on a flank of a tank

What you suggested are also in the suggestion I posted a while back. It was passed along to the devs and I honestly think there will be some additions made with it in the future.

Not true. If you have an elevation advantage, you can often punch through below the turret or other parts too.