I noticed for br2 germany i can put together a pretty good italian army (using premmy, event, bp items) with the exception of a tank, because there aren’t any.
What are some of the standout suggestions over the years for this?
I would really like to see the p40 but I’m not sure it really belongs in br2. I noticed the turan 1, turan 2, and turan 3 tanks but they are “hungarian”. Again not sure if they really count as “Italian”. The turan 2 would be a perfect br2 tank otherwise and turan 3 for br3.
Then there’s the Celere Sahariano which seems like it might be okay for br2. I’m not really seeing anything else on warthunder. Is there anything that hasn’t been added yet or perhaps a way to buff the current br1 semovente to br2 without it being too much?
To all the italian enthusiasts, what are your thoughts?
3 Likes
I mean the M14 is ok. I prefer to use it over the Semovente and it treats me fairly well. If you manage to flank the sides of enemy tanks it does fine and it’s decent at anti personnel.
I believe the p40 would make a fantastic BR III tank. Lightish armour but a strong gun that would more than compete. And especially since the Cromwell was added, Italy deserves a BR III tank too.
I believe this would be a great fit for BR II. however would it be a premium or TT? Considering it’s a premium tank in WT, wouldn’t it also be a premium in enlisted? Other than that, I see no reason why it shouldn’t be added, as it’s pretty much an analogue to the T50 and Crusader.
1 Like
I don’t think cromwell should of gone to br3. It’s a little step up from crusader.
I don’t think just because something is premmy in warthunder it should be premmy here. I don’t particularly care if it’s event, but don’t think they should paywall the only real br2 italian tank available
1 Like
Well yes it can be BR II if they manage to balance it like the Chaffee
M24 | War Thunder Wiki
P40 | War Thunder Wiki
If not they can give tank destroyer:
75/34 M43 | War Thunder Wiki
or
Celere Sahariano | War Thunder Wiki
That’s some of the best options. But even P40 can be BR II since will be super bad at BR III and P40 was used by Germany and Italy so will be very interesting BR II option.

P40 is more of a BR II tank then BR III. It has more armor but is it that amazing Its hard to tell to me will be just Axis Chaffee.
3 Likes
I’m not looking at stats but i believe the p40 has significantly better armor.
Well its better yes but still can be penned by majority of BR II tanks so vs BR I will be bad probably. But in BR III P40 sounds like very bad tank.
Axis already has a surplus of tanks, and therefore should not receive any more.
Sound familiar, hm?
No? Not really. If i said something like that it’s because whatever was redundant/truly not needed. Fleshing out sub factions hold way more importance than some slight varient. There should be Italian and british squads/equipment in all BRs if possible since they are such a big part of the game already. I would also like to see other sub factions get more love as well. Brings way more life to the game than another thompson, or panzer 3/4.
1 Like
Nothing
Italian cars are mostly garbage and For a very specific amateur
There’s more than armored cars available
I was just saying)
if they add it, I just won’t touch it)
As I recall, some people mentioned that the P43 was partially completed; furthermore, there are several tank destroyer variants that were produced by the Germans in Italian factories following Italy’s surrender in 1943, but I don’t believe any of these would qualify for a BR higher than BR3.
I really would prefer to see an Italian APC but any other additions are welcome.
1 Like
That thing can’t be BR2 It have 100mm armor inmortal for nearly all br2-3 tanks except the 76mm ones and the T-34-57 I used It on wt is pretty fun stop all shells except german ones they get OP canons
And abouth the P40 they could just send It to BR3 with APHE and HEAT Heat is enougth for KVs and front Pen shermans and T-34s at Br2 I think the tank would be too overkill except for the bad coaxial MG but the armor is just too good for Br2 at least thats what i think
No tis equal to 70 mm of armor (sloped at ~45°) So its either very good BR II tank or very bad BR III tank and if its premium for sure no one will buy it in BR III.
And it have a frontal weak spot so everything that can pen 50 mm can pen it. So Crusader has no problem at all. It will be problem for the Soviet faction since they dont have good BR II tank but for the allies not so much.
1 Like
That spot on the turret is really small. It’s like a 2.5br tank maybe, and for it to fit the standard of br2 it wouldn’t be allowed any heat, apcbc, nor aphe. Only solid ap. That would suck. I’d rather get good shells in br3 for it. Armor isn’t that important if you can frontally penn all other br3 tanks which i believe it should be able to.
1 Like
Well that’s the problem with the tank it will be too good for BR II and too bad for BR III since its worse then the Cromwell and the Cromwell is not very popular.
I’d have to disagree. A 75mm gun will perform way better in br3 than a 50 whatever mm gun