The Ka-Chi Needs a Buff

  • Yes
  • No
0 voters

The Ka-Chi is simply too weak to be a BR 2 tank.

It should either be moved down to BR 1 or receive some other meaningful buffs.

It’s not that the Ka-Chi has no advantages. However, its disadvantages far outweigh its strengths. Aside from its premium status, there is very little reason to use this tank at BR 2.

Disadvantages

1. Extremely Poor Mobility

The Ka-Chi is extremely heavy for its engine power, resulting in very poor mobility.

It takes a considerable amount of time to reach your desired combat position, and its sluggish movement makes it difficult to react quickly to changing battlefield situations.

2. Terrible Hull Traverse

When attempting to turn while moving forward, the Ka-Chi struggles to rotate its hull smoothly, resulting in awkward, sluggish movements.

Combined with its already poor mobility, this makes the tank feel even slower and more cumbersome to operate.

3. Weak Armor

Despite having mobility comparable to that of a heavy tank, the Ka-Chi has surprisingly thin armor.

Its large spaced armor does provide effective protection against infantry anti-tank rockets. However, in tank-versus-tank combat, it struggles to withstand the main guns of other BR 2 vehicles, such as the Crusader and M3 Lee.

More importantly, its turret armor is even weaker than its hull armor.

Enemy tanks can easily disable the Ka-Chi simply by targeting its turret, even if they are BR 1 vehicles.

4. Extremely Weak Firepower

Despite having mobility comparable to a heavy tank, the Ka-Chi offers no significant advantage in either anti-tank or anti-infantry combat.

Its main gun is barely adequate for tank combat, and even then, it is inferior to the guns mounted on the Crusader and M3 Lee.

Its anti-infantry capabilities are even worse.

The Ka-Chi does not have a single usable machine gun.

Furthermore, its relatively small-caliber main gun makes its HE shells significantly less effective against infantry compared to those of other BR 2 tanks.

Considering the complete lack of machine guns, its overall firepower is practically at BR 1 level.

5. Severely Restricted Visibility

As if weak armor and poor firepower weren’t enough, the Ka-Chi also suffers from extremely limited visibility!

When operating the Ka-Chi, you cannot stick your head out of the hatch or use binoculars.

Instead, you are forced to rely entirely on the commander’s cupola view and the gunner’s sight throughout the match.

If the Ka-Chi’s enormous hull gets stuck on a building, tree, or other obstacle, figuring out exactly what part of the vehicle is caught, freeing yourself, and getting back on your intended route can take an absurd amount of time.

Furthermore, even if you manage to spot enemy infantry approaching from the flank, your chances of dealing with them are practically zero.

Your hull traverse is slow, you have no machine guns, and your main gun has a relatively small caliber.

Advantages — And Why They Barely Matter

Of course, the Ka-Chi does have some advantages.

First, it has a large crew of seven, allowing you to replace fallen crew members multiple times during combat.

If you manage to reach an objective, you can even dismount the crew and use them almost like an infantry squad.

It also has the ability to float and travel across water.

However, these advantages are practically meaningless when compared to its numerous disadvantages.

They simply aren’t enough to compensate for the tank’s weaknesses.

The M3 Lee also has a seven-man crew, so having a large crew isn’t even a unique advantage of the Ka-Chi.

And because of its terrible mobility, there’s a good chance that you’ll either be destroyed before reaching the objective or that your teammates will have already captured it and moved on to the next one.

As for its amphibious capability, the tank’s movement and rocking on the water make accurate shooting extremely difficult, severely limiting its effectiveness against both tanks and infantry.

More importantly, Enlisted offers very few situations where the ability to float is actually useful.

Conclusion

The Ka-Chi has poor mobility, sluggish hull traverse, weak armor, inadequate firepower, and severely restricted visibility.

Its few advantages do not come close to compensating for these weaknesses.

As a premium vehicle, it should offer a reasonable level of combat effectiveness, but in its current state, there is little practical reason to choose it over other BR 2 tanks.

I believe the Ka-Chi should be moved down to BR 1 or receive substantial buffs to make it a viable option at BR 2.

I suggest reducing the Ka-Chi’s crew from seven to five and moving it down to BR 1. (This would involve removing the two crew members inside the hull who serve no actual function.)

I believe crew sizes can be adjusted for balancing purposes, just as the LVT(A)-1 previously had a crew of four but was later buffed to six.

2 Likes

This thing and Chi-He should be BR 1 instead honestly

3 Likes

No, It got very good front armor
15mm + 50mm space armor, big hull, large crew
Survivability is not a weakness of this tank.

This tank should be at BR 1.

2 Likes

I didn’t know that this large point box was BR2. After checking just now, it seems that way. However, the Ka-Chi is a useful weapon in limited environments. Specifically, when conducting bombardment from the water, it can hide its massive hull, so effective use is only possible in ocean zones on Pacific maps. That said, it feels unnatural for it to be BR2 based on that alone

1 Like

It has a 7 man crew and spaced armor with a 47mm gun it’s not br1 add a roof mounted machine gun

where is poll?

wad1

Your argument is reasonable, but unfortunately, the Ka-Chi’s armor isn’t actually that good. Even with the additional armor provided by its flotation pontoons, it can still be easily penetrated by the main gun of the BR 1 Stuart.

Its armor may seem thick against certain tanks, but Soviet BR 1 tanks equipped with 45mm guns share the same gun as the T-50, allowing them to penetrate the Ka-Chi’s hull at close range without much difficulty.

1 Like

The Ka-Chi is designed in a way that prevents the commander from opening the hatch and sticking their head out, so mounting a machine gun on the turret isn’t an option.

Simply having spaced armor and a 47mm gun is not enough to justify keeping it at BR 2. Its overall performance simply isn’t up to BR 2 standards.

1 Like

And a crew of seven
And it’s too good for br1 the problem with compression of having 7 hrs of war thunder if 5 of enlisted drop at least 2 crew members and some slight nerfs to the gun maybe,n but just dropping it to br1 is a nono when tanks have as 5hin armor and a few of 2

The tank with only two crew members you’re referring to is the T-60 from the regular tech tree. The problem isn’t that the Ka-Chi is overwhelmingly stronger than the T-60. It’s that the T-60 itself is an exceptionally underpowered tank.

The T-60 has such poor anti-tank capabilities that it can’t even destroy a BR 1 Panzer III J from the sides or rear. Comparing such an underperforming vehicle to the Ka-Chi is simply not a fair comparison.

In fact, comparing the Ka-Chi to the BR 1 Panzer III J makes my point even clearer.

The Panzer III J has at least 50mm of frontal armor across its entire front, a 5cm main gun with even better penetration than the Ka-Chi’s 47mm gun, both coaxial and hull-mounted machine guns, and a commander who can open the hatch and look outside.

It’s even faster than the Ka-Chi!

The Ka-Chi is inferior to the BR 1 Panzer III J in most performance categories. If your argument is that the Ka-Chi deserves to remain at BR 2 simply because it has more crew members, then by that logic, the LVT(A)-1 should be at BR 2, and the M3 Lee should be at BR 3.

Having a large crew is practically useless as an advantage when almost every other aspect of the vehicle’s performance is so poor.

1 Like

with the kai chi
Then you shouldn’t mind giving up two crew members
It should either be moved down to BR 1 or receive some other meaningful buffs.
Where is th buff suggestion
This should have been in br

Of course. That’s exactly my point.

The Ka-Chi’s seven-man crew is practically meaningless at BR 2.

Even at BR 2, you’d be better off bringing the BR 1 Chi-Ha Kai instead. It has both a hull-mounted machine gun and a turret-mounted machine gun, and even allows the commander to stick his head out of the hatch.

I’m not even joking when I say that removing two crew members, reducing the crew to five, and moving the Ka-Chi down to BR 1 would make it a much more viable tank.

That’s how little those two extra crew members actually matter.

ok then add it - 2 crew from 7 to 5

I’ve added it to the main post. Do you agree with the proposal now?

yep, thank you