I started playing about one month ago after a break of roughly a year, possibly longer.
Tanks have become absolutely unusable, and I say this for a variety of reasons which I’m gonna list down below. Despite being a Germany main this problem surely affects all factions.
Mobility
This is the most important point of this rant. It wasn’t this bad once. The problems are endless. Tracks don’t seem to have any grip anymore, even the slightest incline is enough to reduce your speed by 90% or often even stop you completely. Turning while going uphill immediately stops you in your tracks and even trying to turn on the spot won’t work while being on a slope (no matter how gentle it is). One-meter-wide trenches will get a Tiger II stuck. Hell, even a small crater will get it stuck. Any piece of environmental clutter will get it stuck: crushed vehicles, pile of crates/barrels, tiny piles of rubble, wooden fences, log piles, train tracks, etc.
Please for the love of God make tracks work like tracks and not like wet soap bars.
Visibility
Playing tank is like playing blind. There is way too much visual clutter. I understand that infantry needs its space for balance reasons, but tank gameplay can’t be this crippled. Bushes, trees, relicts, and horrible map design makes landing a good shot almost impossible. With the introduction of the guerrilla squads the restrictions on map boundaries were definitely overkill. Forget about finding a decent spot with a good field of view: you’ll be forced to get close (WAY too close) and this will bring you directly to the squad selection menu. Why? Aside from the aforementioned mobility there’s another aspect that needs to be talked about:…
Survivability
Everything counters tanks. Tanks trump nothing. They get bullied by every single infantry squad: every soldier can carry explosive packs and/or TNT charges and EVERY single AT weapon easily penetrates even the front armor of every tank of its respective tier. Panzerschreks and Panzerfausts 100 in the hands of every faction make armour utterly useless. You don’t even need strategy, flanking or anything else: just aim at the tank and you’ll one-shot it.
There’s also aircraft, but that wouldn’t be a problem if it weren’t for the abysmal mobility that makes moving away from bombs utterly and absolutely impossible. You hear a plane engine approaching? Start thinking about what squad to pick next, because you WON’T SURVIVE, EVER.
And I think that’s pretty much it. Honestly I don’t think that the last two points will ever be addressed by the devs, but they are the least important ones. What needs to be ABSOLUTELY fixed is the horrid mobility, ASAP. Especially the (nonexistent) grip of the tracks on the ground.
No one likes warthunder campers. There are loads of good vantage points, what we don’t need are spots like you’re talking about where a tank can control the entire map and kill the whole team at natural spawn point.
I mean besides the traction problem tanks back in WW2 used to be like that, clumsy and claustrophobic metal boxes. I know the transition from agile light tanks in lower BRs to slower vehicles that now have to face anti-tank weapons with massive penetration and experienced players might be shocking for players, that’s just the natural transition to BR III.
Maybe there’s a workaround — just make the map more destructible. Let a direct hit blow up trees, prop vehicles, sandbags, crates, all that. Then you wouldn’t have to crush through them or nail them with HE rounds just to clear the way.
It’s not about camping, it’s about being useful and strategical. He didn’t said that he want a place where to control the entire map, but at least the possibility of being useful without running litterally in front of the enemy in a game where any single soldier carry an AT weapon. Because we all know that anybody has explosion pack or TNT.
There are nice shades of gray in the middle. If the map would be less cluttered with an absurd amount of “STUFF” you could use the tank as it should be used, at range. Maybe helping one side, not covering the entire map from that spot.
And still, there are plenty of dedicated AT squads. If a tank is well positioned and is giving the support he is suppose to, then somebody has to take an AT squad, or another Tank itself, or an airplane. This is how it should be.
Cluttering the map with just everything in order to avoid tank to have a view more far away than 10 meters in order to make it run in front of the enemy so it can be killed and encircled with no problem is not the way to manage this.
That’s not how it used to be in WW2, for example a Tiger 2 was use to run 30km/h at road and 20 offroad. That’s not even close for example. But anyway, we are not even complaining on speed. We are complaining about the mechanics of how TRACKS in this game are not working as they should.
It is absurd to see a Tank sliding, it is absurd to see a tank blocking because there is 1 rock on the ground, not a big one, a small one. Tanks are designed to pass over trenches, even the old WW1 model did that, it’s ridiculous how often you just cant pass a small trench with a huge BR5 end war tank.
You can’t say that’s correct how the tanks behave when they have to overcome a single crater or a rock.
When a tank is shooting from the backline you have 12 enemy players that can
1 Take a tank themself and shoot him and they already know where he is
2 Take an airplane and bomb it
3 Take an AT squad and shoot him the rocket in the front (it penetrate easly even the most armored)
If in 12 people, nobody does that, and the tank is just sitting there unharmed, then sorry you deserve to being dominated from him. The solution is not removing any possible strategical tank gameplay putting tons of clutter, removing his mobility to climb upper areas, and make it so unable to stay at range in order that he must come to suicide in frontline if he wanna do a few kills.
There are a lot of different way to kill a tank at range. If in the entire enemy team noone does that, you deserve it.
I really do not care if “ww2 used to be like that”, this is an arcade game, not a simulator. If i wanted a simulator I’d go and play Hell Let Loose or Squad 44.
That being said I can assure you I’ve been playing BR5 for a long time even before my year-long break, and I repeat myself: it wasn’t this bad before. I already know about experienced players and overpowered AT weapons (nor that it changes anything at lower BRs: low BR AT weapon defeats low BR armor too, everything is just upscaled). What I’m talking about is the humongous mobility nerf that ALL tanks suffered, both low and high BR. They move like rotting corpses and get stuck on literally everything on the map, and that is simply not balanced nor fair.
It’s not removed though? Again, there are tons of vantage spots way in the back. I’m not saying that’s a problem, but it would be if they can see everything including natural spawns for both infantry and vehicles.
No, there aren’t “tons”, I don’t know which maps are you playing, but the ones I play at BR5 absolutely don’t have “tons” of vantage spots in the back.
The very FEW vantage spots are almost impossible to reach due to the abysmal mobility.
If you can reach them it will take you a very long time to do so, often enough for the enemy team to capture the point and force you to reposition (at 5km/h max, IF you don’t get stuck on a crumpled up newspaper).
Even if you reach the vantage spot it will be too far forward and you’ll get blown up by an explosive pack/TNT charge in less than 3 minutes straight.
Holy strawman. You’re imagining things. This never happened, isn’t happening now, won’t happen in the future, and no one in this topic asked for this or even thought about asking for this.
I don’t spend much time looking at enlistedrollcall, but maybe it can shed light on this. My personal experience is that earning XP on many maps is very easy with tanks. My highest k/d games are all tank gameplay bar none. I’ve had over 100 kills with no deaths with a tank and not come anywhere near that with any infantry squad.
Well then wtf are you asking for? OP is complaining saying he wants a protected camping spot way in the back that can easily control the field. Be so serious. He’s complaining about too many trees in wooded areas and too many buildings in towns, be so serious.
Tank combat is in a good spot right now. Everyone is on board with better mobility. But all this other b*tching is ridiculous. There’s already lots of camping spots available for tanks. He has yet to learn the maps. That’s his problem.
I don’t get if you really don’t understand the difference between “supreme camping spot dominating entire map” and “removing the gargantuan amount of clutter in order to be able to stay at range” or if you just pretend to do not understand it.
But let’s say it’s the first case, so i explain. If you do remember time ago in the map D-Day there was a spot for defenders on the right hill where a tank could watch the entire map with no cover at all for infantry and kill almost anything everywhere. That was absolutly not correct, i do agree, even if, still… you have 12 people who could just pick a tank wich is always preloaded with AP aganist the camping tank wich 99% is HE loaded and shoot him because you already know where he is. Also you can just pick a bomber and bomb it. But okay, even if the counter is pretty easy, i do agree that a position like that is too much an advantage. But we are not asking for that.
It is true that on SOME maps… at SOME step of the game, you have some spot where you can play at range but they are really few, and for the most of the situation you just have no line of sight for the interested area because of the clutter objects and wreckeges etc. As i said we don’t ask for a position like “ok i see everything from here” but at least a clear view on a cone, a side of the map.
It would be less frustrating this situation if AT LEAST infantry AT weapon would be restricted to dedicated AT squad. For example TNT only avaiable to AT squad. And explosive pack not so effective anymore on BR5 heavy tanks. But we are living in the situation wich litterally anything can destroy a tank, unite this to the fact that most often you can’t stay at range to be effective, and you feel just being trolled by the game.
So the mobility thing is i think very shared from everybody.
For the line of sight and possibility to stay at range as i said we ask for an improvement, not for a godlike spot. Just be able to be useful at range more often then now. Because as i said, be at range doesn’t mean you can’t be killed. There are dedicated squad to counter tank, and those should be used to remove tanks.
At this point I’m gonna assume you’re just trolling, because there is no way you can’t grasp a concept this simple.
There are 2 extremes:
A godlike spot in a gray zone, surrounded by bunkers and offering a height advantage that gives you a perfect view of an otherwise flat map, allowing you to pinpoint every single enemy soldier all the way back to their original spawn.
No (reachable) spot with a height advantage whatsoever. Trees every 3 meters, car/truck/tram wrecks, sandbag piles, lamp posts, piles of rubble, fences, shacks, walls, smoking tank wrecks, bushes, sign posts, bobbins, crates, barrels, cheval de frise, czech hedgehogs, train cars, etc. in the way. (everything i listed stops tanks shells mid-air and most of them can’t even be destroyed by them, must be run over directly)
Do you realize that there can be a middle ground between these two extremes, right? Can you conceptualize a middle ground where a tank doesn’t wipe the enemy team repeatedly and at the same time doesn’t have to play 70 meters away from the capture point, can you? I hope you do.
Oh, and another thing: “B-but tanks can’t play from a distance for muh balance!”
You’re wrong, tanks should play from a distance exactly for balance. There are many ways in which you can dispose of a tank. You can shoot at it with your own tank (with the surprise effect to your advantage), bomb it with a plane, snipe it with your panzerschreck or simply flanking it with your guerrilla squad. If a team of 12 can’t take care of a single tank then it deserves to be dominated and the tank player deserves to win the match with 250+ kills and zero deaths. Having tanks nerfed and incapacitated into oblivion because noobs don’t know how to counter them is not the answer.
Tanks being forced into playing at brawling distance only to get rushed with explosive packs in less than 2 minutes is not balanced nor fair, and this is not an opinion but a fact.
You can literally still do this without being on very top.
You can also dominate the beach on the normandy map from way in the grey zone far away.
Again, lack of map knowledge is a you problem
Lol, it’s “an arcade game” right? Small maps packed with lots of players equals high action, the matches are quick paced. The majority of players do not want camping tanks to be in an even better position than they are now. Tanks are already able to rack up significant infantry kills. No tank main should be getting 200-300+ kills a match on the regular. If you know what you’re doing you can already easily break 100.