Russian Bias + Only BR3 opponents against BR2 = Unplayable

I like to play with German faction on BR2 but this became unplayable.

Playing against overpowered USSR troops is a nightmare because of this unbelievable Russia bias but player almost EVERY game again BR3 when oneself being BR2 against the even more overpowered BR3 USSR troops is worse than a nightmare.

How can thee devs ever hope that there will be enough idiots daring to player BR2 to fix this issue?

So in the end from 5 battle ratings only 2 are playable: BR3 (slaughterin BR2) and BR5 because there is nothing above it.

And in case the devs do not care about this why don’t you even try to do something:
2 ideas:

  • Group BR1+BR2, BR3+BR4 and BR5 on its own
  • give players with the lower BR in a mixed game more score/silver whatever.

But doing nothing kills the game.

7 Likes

Soviet faction is the strongest at BR III, at least in terms of capableness on a given BR.
Its not a big surprise that players would stack the faction and BR that gives them the best chance to get the 25K points as quickly as possible.

Axis and Japan BR V is also very stacked with veterans at the moment…

However I will agree that BR III has became way too popular across all factions for two reasons: its the best BR to bully newer players and the chances of getting uptiered is by far the lowest of any BR (except BR V obviously).
There are many players that are still playing starter bolt-actions, unupgraded weapons and only have a few (often less worthy) BR II weapons getting sent to BR II-III hell. These people are essentially XP pinatas.

One easy solution would be to code match making to make BR III-IV battles more common, so BR III gets uptiers more commonly.

14 Likes

Well, BR3 is also popular because you get to play most of the Iconic weapons of WW2.

I do play BR3 any faction most of the time because this is also the most populated and enjoying BR to play. Almost every gear at this BR is good enough to be played. Sure SMG are still dominant (juste like every BR except 5) but the semi auto rifle, MG and even Flamethrowers can be played without much issue.

Yes the issue is that BR2 kinda struggles, but its not unplayable either.

I would recommand playing the second day of each 2-day step of an event as most of the try hard usually complete the tasks on the first day and as result you encounter less of them on the second day (at least this is what I experienced)

5 Likes

Well I mean, what I like to do in the case of a unfortunate uptier from BR2 would be to use a Panzer 4F (for the HEAT shells) as the main anti tank/inf killer, I would use the commando/grueillas, engineers, machine gunners (with MG13s), and snipers

1 Like

i play a lot of german br2 and soviet br3 and up/downtiers happen quite frequently during event days. better get used to it.

For the average solo player, nothing has really improved. If you value your time, deserting most battles is still the only reasonable option.

I play late at night, so the problem is even more noticeable.

BR I should have strict MM +0, similar to the early days of the CBT. It already has enough bolt-action rifles and SMGs to offer variety without having to face higher-tier equipment. Right now, BR I is dominated by weapons like the PPS. On top of that, you can’t even use an APC to provide additional support to your team, and you’re limited to a single rally point — often the only one your entire team builds. Throw in a terrible map, and you’ve got a recipe for defeat.

By the way, where the hell is Moscow for BR I???

BR II has been suffering from a similar problem lately. PPSh spam is everywhere, despite the weapon being perfectly capable of holding its own even at BR V. Events are irrelevant here because they’re practically running all the time anyway. Playing defense against BR III is especially pointless and feels like a complete waste of time.

There’s no point in writing an essay about it. Countless threads have already discussed these same issues. We’re all playing the same game under the same conditions. I’ve simply chosen to leave most battles rather than waste my time on matches that feel unplayable.

I feel the pain in this post, but I want to gently push back on the “Russian bias” framing — because I think the real problem is something much more fundamental, and it’s one that hurts every faction’s newcomers, not just the German side.

Think about what actually happens to a brand-new player who came to this game specifically to play Germany. They slog through BR I, getting farmed by veterans who dropped down to grind event points, and eventually unlock BR II. And what do they actually have at that point?

Maybe three infantry squads. The squad progression system is so grindy that most of those squads are under-strength bolt-action squads — half the slots empty, or filled with half-leveled soldiers. They probably haven’t unlocked or upgraded Engineers yet, so they’ve got no real incentive to build rally points, and they’re not about to waste a squad slot on an even weaker Engineer just to do it. Their only real weapon is an MP40 that feels like a peashooter against what they’re about to face.

Then the matchmaker throws them into BR II-III, and they get to eat high-rate-of-fire full-auto SMGs — again and again and again. Not because the other side is “overpowered,” but because the other side is full of veterans who’ve been playing for years, sitting in BR III where the queue is most populated, farming fresh BR II players who have nothing to fight back with.

It’s a matchmaking problem combined with a new-player onboarding problem. And this is exactly why so few new players stick around — not because “Russia is OP,” but because the first hunders hours of this game are a meat grinder with no pity for the people at the bottom of it.

Matchmaker needs to produce more BR III-IV games so BR III stops being the default “farm BR II” tier. But even that won’t save new players if the onboarding itself — the squad progression, the Engineer unlock, the first weapons — stays as punishing as it is now.

DEAR DEVS WHO IS THIS GAME FOR , and how long do we expect a new player to suffer before they get to have fun?

9 Likes

Also one problem that can make BR2 difficult for BR2 is that many of the best weapons of this BR are tied to higher research tier.

For instance, stuff like Type Otsu, Thompson M1A1, Beretta M42 and others are Tier 3 or 4 in the research tree meaning that people will unlock BR3 gears before reaching these weapons. I mean sure they are not mandatory, but they are still some of the best weapons for their factions at this BR.

3 Likes

In BR 5, it’s the same thing, but in reverse: your teammates are running BR 2–3 gear… Just accept that the devs are incompetent and don’t care about the game; keep playing until War Thunder introduces infantry and this piece-of-trash game finally dies for good.

1 Like

It’s true that the game has a terrible matchmaking system, and the devs don’t seem capable of fixing it (at this point, I doubt it’s a matter of them not wanting to—it’s more likely just incompetence). That said, your post is also the work of a total noob. Germany is the strongest faction across all BR [Battle Rating] levels, followed by the USA. I’ll grant you that the teammates you get stuck with are often brain-dead—like they’re playing with stumps instead of hands—but I’ll say it again: your complaint about the campaigns is ridiculous. Germany has everything it needs in BR 1 through 3 to completely dominate the other campaigns.

If you assemble the squads correctly, it’s easy to play

“Germany is the strongest faction” is true and also completely irrelevant to what I said. I’m not complaining about Germany’s weak — I’m describing the experience of a new player who hasn’t unlocked any of that strength yet
A fresh BR II player has three under-strength bolt-action squads and an MP40. It doesn’t matter that Germany is theoretically “complete” at BR 1-3 when that player can’t field any of it — he’s still going to get shredded by BR III veterans with full-auto SMGs. You could hand that new player the strongest faction in the game and the outcome wouldn’t change, because the problem isn’t the faction, it’s the matchmaking and the onboarding.

You literally agreed the matchmaking is broken. So why are you calling me a noob for pointing out the exact same thing, just from the new player’s side instead of yours? :sweat_smile:

1 Like

I have to apologize for one thing—I didn’t realize you were new! xD As for your other point, I agree with you; in fact, 3–4 years ago I complained about that exact same thing. I even used this analogy: “A real-world army wouldn’t hand a commander a tank and say, ‘Go fight 3–4 battles, and if you prove yourself, maybe you’ll unlock the gunner.’” (I was pointing out how vehicles often come incomplete—for instance, with bombers, you have to play at least 20–30 solid matches just to unlock anything beyond the pilot). The devs didn’t respond at all, and the forum community, as usual, pushed back. (Enlisted players seem to suffer from Stockholm syndrome—they’ll defend the company no matter what. That’s why, once you’ve been on the forums for a while, you tend to get a bit aggressive! xD) My apologies again.

In fact, I even tried to push for them to block veterans from accessing BR2—or at least to ensure they wouldn’t be matched against less experienced players, but rather against others with a similar or greater number of hours played. (That, too, was poorly received.) Anyway, you’ll soon realize that any complaint or post calling for improvements is almost always met with a negative reaction here.

As for some tips: with Germany, your best assets are tanks and aircraft. Their weaponry isn’t particularly strong until you reach BR 4 and above. Without a doubt, the best weapon—even up to BR 3—is the MP40; use it, and try to get it to 3 stars—it’s a fantastic, versatile weapon. Germany at BR 3 is actually weaker than at BR 2 or BR 4–5, because their semi-automatic weapons become quite poor and their submachine guns have absurd recoil. Consequently, even at BR 3, you can still defeat the Soviets using BR 2 weaponry. Prioritize the tank line; it’s Germany’s greatest strength—they can wipe out anything and withstand almost any hit.

The Soviets have greater access to submachine guns, but these weapons have very high recoil and empty their entire magazine absurdly fast; play defensively against them and rely on ambushes. As for aircraft, the Soviets are generally quite mediocre, and while their tanks are durable, they aren’t particularly special—they simply can’t compete with German tanks. Against the US, watch out for their infantry; they are very well-equipped, and their aircraft are quite powerful. Their tanks can only defeat a German tank if you position yourself poorly—try angling your tank from side to side when facing them head-on, and it will be impossible for them to penetrate your armor. This holds true until you reach BR 4–5, where the Americans finally possess significant firepower.

Send me a private message if you have any questions; as for the game itself—well, that’s beyond fixing. Like I said before, just wait for War Thunder Infantry to come out, because I doubt the developers here have any intention of making improvements.

1 Like

I just realized I replied to the wrong person earlier xD — anyway, that’s what happens when you’re being nosy while already swamped with work. Regardless, you’re right, and I still maintain that there won’t be any apparent solution.

1 Like

Not biased at all but btw, mostly of ppl in soviets are using zuckerman to farm a lot of points

Appreciate the apology, genuinely — and the tips are solid, so thanks for taking the time. Though I should probably clear one thing up: I’m not actually a new player :woozy_face:

The reason I was talking about new players is that I’ve watched a bunch of people I know bounce off this game at exactly the point I described — and I’ve been on the other side of it too, farming BR II for event points. So when I say “new players suffer,” it’s not me complaining about my own matches; it’s me describing what I’ve seen happen to the people who never make it to the forum at all. That’s the silent majority I keep going on about.

And yeah, on the Stockholm syndrome thing — I’ve seen it. The moment anyone posts a genuine complaint, a chunk of the community shows up to defend the game like it’s paying their rent. I get why that’d make someone cynical after four years of it. But that’s exactly why I’d rather keep pushing the matchmaking/onboarding angle than write the whole game off.

Which brings me to the one part I still disagree with: “Wait for WT infantry”? I actually have a CBT spot, and I still don’t touch it. Haven’t opened War Thunder in several updates. Why? Because the two games are nothing alike. Enlisted is squad-based — that’s the entire point: an AI squad backing you up, switching soldiers, playing as a unit. WT infantry stripped all that out and went solo-respawn, which turns into a corner-camping, bush-ratting mess. I didn’t sign up to crouch in a corner and jumpscare people.

Anyone who thinks WT infantry is the “successor” to Enlisted has either never understood what makes Enlisted work, or they’ve swallowed Gaijin’s blurry marketing where one publisher owns both and everyone assumes the games are interchangeable. They aren’t. So no — I’m not pinning this game’s future on that.

Anyway — no hard feelings from my side, and I do appreciate the pointers. If I ever actually meet a new player who needs them, I’ll pass them along. :smile:

1 Like

It’s true that the infantry gameplay in War Thunder leans more toward Battlefield than Enlisted, but that’s not what I meant. I never really felt like Enlisted was a game about command, because the bots are completely useless—they don’t provide any support, they can’t even save themselves; they’re practically non-existent. You end up forgetting about them entirely until the moment you have to switch to one of them. xD

That’s why I feel that the strength you’re talking about is the least visible thing in Enlisted—though, of course, that’s just my personal experience and opinion after playing this thing for nearly six years.