Overview
The inclusion of historical battle in Enlisted as event is very much welcomed however this event in particular has such a skewed balance with Red Army winning most of the battle. As historically accurate as it is, it doesn’t translate well with gameplay enjoyment. I will try to use historical source and gameplay logic to justify the change needed for this event to be enjoyable for both factions. Because this is just a game and Enlisted could not simulate the devastation of the Red Army officer corp following Stalin’s Great Purge or German Army exhausted supply line during Operation Typhoon, this will be only equipment based.
1. Limit the amount of SVT-40 for the Red Army by replacing it with Mosin-Nagant 91/30
This is from gameplay perspective, the German faction currently don’t have any semi-automatic rifle while Red Army has tons of SVT-40 (BR4 rifle), disadvantaging the German enormously.
Historically SVT-40 was already mass fielded by the Red Army on paper, with Tula Arm reported that its factory supplied the front with 88,000 SVT-40 rifles in July 1941 and another 100,000 in August, alongside sniper rifles. But Mosin-Nagant 91/30 still the main rifle for the Red Army and SVT-40 was more complicated to manufacture and during Barbarossa, most of these rifle fell to the German and the Mosin-Nagant 91/30 became the standard issue until the production was improved.
And yes since historically most of the German Army were still operating using bolt-action Kar98k and Gewehr 41, both Walther and Mauser variant were adopted on smaller number due to its unreliability, I feel like it should not be added to this event.
Should the Red Army have limited SVT-40?
- Yes
- No
2. PTRS-41 should be reduced to one squad, and give the rest of the squad the PTRD-41
This event literally made German tanks so useless since the PTRS-41 and its scoped variant just straight sniped them out of existence.
Since PTRD-41 was cheaper to produce and was more widely available to the Red Army compared to PTRS-41 during the Defense of Moscow, I feel like it’s no-brainer that PTRD-41 should be equipped by the Red Army AT squad
Should PTRS-41 be reduced to one squad, and give the rest of the AT squad the PTRD-41?
- Yes
- No
3. Give the Red Army T-26 and BT-7
During the Battle of Moscow, the Red Army wasn’t armor-less (Duh), it still have sizeable light tank forces. While I’m tempted to give them access to T-34 (1941) and KV-1, the German would complain that it is virtually invincible to the cannon of German tanks of that time. Only through superior infantry tactic, air superiority, CAS support, 88cm Flak Gun, and realibility problem with many of T-34s and KV-1s having mechanical breakdown, and poor crew training that the German managed to overcome them albeit temporarily. If T-34s and KV-1 were to be added, the German should have at least be given CAS option such as the Ju-87 D variant.
Should the Red Army be given T-26 and BT-7?
- Yes
- No