Move the Xa-38 to BR4 where it belongs

Now that’s where you are wrong… because ever since the merge the devs have clearly made it known they want all nations to be on par with each other such as giving Americans t20, japs type hei auto… Pershing… some of the notable ones.

Just because it can one or two tap any tank doesn’t mean it’s super effective in gameplay. It has no HE rounds, so there’s no using it like a normal auto cannon to kill infantry, it’s only use is for targeting tanks. You literally only have enough time to get 2 shots off during a pass and in which case you take that second shot you typically loose your chance to drop a bomb accurately on the tank. So it’s usually either one or the other. It’s way too risky to solely rely on it, most people will just shoot once, miss and go for the bomb drop. It practically has zero sway in the tide of battle. Some 20mm auto cannons would of been way more effective for defensive armaments.

You can have balance without having copy pasted armaments. Again, bombload alone isn’t fair to compare planes against each other. The russian medium bombers in br3 get multiple bombs plus rockets and/or 20-30mm auto cannons. A plane can easily make up for it’s lesser bombload with other things to make it balanced. So again, every nation does not need the exact same shit as the other. You are wrong. Yes, u.s. got pershing, but tiger2 is still king of the tanks, and they also have the tiger and panther in br4 which is FAR superior than anything else, especially when compared to the U.S.

I mean I don’t know what to tell you… it requires skill to use and greatly rewards it… just earlier I used it and yes you can only get two or three shots off before you pass but all you need is one properly placed shot… and also you can use the mgs to get an idea of where the cannon is going to land

That’s not its purpose… in game it’s to attack tanks… which is is very good at… now it’s nowhere near the yak 9ks ability to do such because of it slower fire rate and maneuverability but it still shreds.

I dunno, skill issue? Sure, I’ve missed by shots and went back to drops. Bomb and just get intercepted but that’s what happens… my squad mate likes to sue this plane a lot and absolutely demolishes with the cannon… saving the bombs for infantry… and I have had good luck with it myself primarily against German tanks as id assume they have more ammo across the inside to detonate

I would disagree… I think it’s a nice side piece to have when combating armor as like I said to save your bombs for infantry… sure defensive wise 20mm would be awesome… but you didn’t design the plane now did you.

I

I wholeheartedly disagree with that… bomb load is arguably the most prominent thing when choosing a plane… and having an imbalance in between the armaments creates an issue… I mean again look at su2s what? 6! 100kgs to spread out while having good fight stats and offensive armaments vs 2 250s on what I’d consider to be a terrible flying experience (Stuka, fanboys will disagree) with shitcan mg 17 vs chad ShKAS

That is just not right… but you can disagree we both have our opinions.

You are saying xa 38s bomb load in the BR is fine because it’s NEAR tech tree equivalent ishoukd be BRIV? I mean… it’s been stated that event stuff is allowed to be like this because it’s limited… so your solution is to add the even better version of it down to 3?

To clarify… I don’t think you should reasonably be using its cannon as a reason for its uptier… it’s primarily the bombs… and it can do just fine defending itself with the 360 gunner… but isn’t the best at actively going after other planes… unlike the a20 with its arrangement of 12.7… which arguable is a reason to keep its BR placement though… but I digress.

What are you saying here? I’m talking about suspended armament as a whole… yknow the fact it has rockets plus bombs is definitely imbalanced towards the other ones… the il2 1941 really has no downsides I can think of off hand and even il2m I believe just has worse turn rate… meanwhile the 110 doesn’t get near its power at the same br.

I don’t think the il2s are balanced at all compared to Germany’s LET ALONE Japan’s planes… furthermore look at its. R1 biplane… amazing guns, rockets! And biplane turning… vs hs 123 and a fucking floatplane? I mean come on! Although that is genuinely Soviet Bias.

That is both our opinions… but when I said you are wrong I meant that the devs do not share the same feeling as you when looking at other things… there are also plenty other examples… I mean people wanted high capacity smg for Germany because all other nations get one and look what happened?

This is drifting off topic… and arguing serves no purpose.

The yak 1 is by far the optimal choice for br1? The bi plane with rockets ain’t much to talk about. Germany has the bf109 in br1 plus the cn2001 premmy which are such powerful planes that u.s. and japan can’t compete with on any level. The br1 109 is so good that i still use it up to br3 where a single 50kg bomb takes Shermans out with ease. Germany definitely gets some “bias” of it’s own. Germany’s bf 110 g2 and fiat need to be br3, which the community largely agrees with. But even if they arent, each nation has very clear advantages in some regards throughout each battle rating. Each nation is not a complete one for one, and it’s people like you who complain about it. (Japan has the best br3 figher in the game)

Then move all the Bf-110s to rank 4 that would be a fair trade while we’re at it any German armor that gets a APCBC shell at rank 2 should be moved to rank III where they belong.

There’s still time to delete this before anyone else sees it schlawg

2 Likes

Sure sure if Bf110 also gets 4x 250kg bombs and 75mm gun while still retains over 600 km/h speed

Damn, i guess Panzer 4 F1/E with KwK 37 75mm APCBC which has 50mm penetration at point blank range belongs to BR 3 now.

3 Likes

yup

If the XA-38 is moved to BR4 its flight characteristics need to be addressed; it isn’t very good at turning—it flies like a brick and is hard to handle. Its turning performance would need to be improved.

Don’t care if they do, but I also think it’s okay for something in a faction to be better in one aspect. Just like bf109 gets 4 bombs in br1, compared to the awful 2x 250lb gp bombs for u.s… which are quite comparable to one another despite the weight difference.

It is, i’m okay with that too.
However, there’s a threshold for how much better they can get and i think XA-38 crossed that threshold. LIke Su-2 on BR 2 having 6x 100kg bombs, when one faction literally gets double the amount of payload when the other factions usually get without little to no downside then i don’t think they are just being better, they are overpowered.

Everyone got something good on BR 1 for fighter except Japan in terms of payload. 4x 50 kg bombs on german, 2x 100 kg bombs on soviet, 2x 250 lbs bombs on US. Japan is the only one having only 2x 60 kg bombs.

1 Like

These are similar stats to the 50kg bombs on bf109. Except the 109 gets double the payload. That’s my point.

The only payload that comes close to being balanced with it is the 2 100kg bombs for russia

Also the hurricane is straight trash. The bf109 and yak1 are so good i can use them in br3 exceptionally well. I’d say that’s overpowered.

Still more powerful than 50 or 60 kg tho. Just not as good as 2x 100 kg or 4x 50 kg.

I don’t think so. Hurricane is better at turn fight at least than the other two i believe.

You can use them but definitely not as good as other BR 3 fighters. These two simply cannot compete with P-51 or Ki-100. Altho if you wanted to use the example of other BR 1 airplane being OP then you could have mentioned Re.2001 CN which is not only great at turn fight but also with 1x 250kg bomb on BR 1.

It’s a negligible difference. The german 250kg is stronger than the u.s. 500lb?

Yes, i have it. It’s not really useful to the point though. Which is the 109 has double the payload just like the xa does.

XA-38 uses 500lbs AN-M64A1 bomb which is more powerful than the german 250 kg bomb. In fact, it is the most powerful bomb in the 250 kg bomb category.

1x 250 kg >>> 4x 50 kg bomb simple as. ESPECIALLY when you are trying to bomb enemy tanks. For instance, you have to be very precise with your bomb in order to kill something like KV-1 with 50 kg alone even then if KV-1 moves up a bit then you are unlikely to kill it. With 250 kg bomb, much much easier.

Yes, i understand, it’s got nothing to do with the argument though. The 250lb gp bomb is on pretty equal footing to both the 50kg bomb on bf109 and the 60kg jap bomb. The whole argument is the bf109 gets double the payload. Just like the xa does compared to the bf110. The max damage again is negligible for the bomb size, however the 250kg gets almost 50% more fragments. One can argue that doesn’t really mean anything. Either way, in my opinion, the difference between the bf109 and the hurricane is the same as the xa vs bf110.

We can also bring up the vast difference in br4 tanks with germany having the panther and tiger. They are straight up better. Just like the xa is better than the 110. We see nations getting significant advantages all over the place.

And i told you that’s not exactly the case because 250 lbs IS more powerful bomb than 50 kg and 60 kg. Is 2x 250 lbs worse than 4x 50 kg? Sure of course. Is it straight up downgrade without any upside? I don’t think so. I think 250 lbs bomb is particularly better at killing infantry due to the strangely high fragment damage. At least i felt like it does when i used it.

Also, i wouldn’t mind 4x 50 kg bombs on bf109 gets nerfed. As long as all other airplanes with BS overpowered loadout for their BR gets nerfed as well. Su-2, XA-38, F-80A etc etc all of them.

Not when XA-38 actually gets more powerful bomb on top of double the payload.

Not when XA-38 actually gets more powerful bomb on top of double the payload.

Also, at least 4x 50 kg bombs on BR 1 have some competitors like 2x 100 kg bombs on Soviet. Name one BR 3 attacker plane that’s comparable to the one which has the most powerful 4x ‘250kg’ class of bombs with still retaining over 600 km/h and 75mm gun for killing tanks. Go ahead.

Oh, should i start bringing Calliope and Firefly(reloads 17 pdr with APDS every ~5 secs btw)on BR 4? I don’t think they are vastly inferior than the Tiger 1 and Panther? I’d start agreeing with you if Tiger 1 gets a dual 88mm gun or some shit just like the XA-38 gets double the payload. Maybe. :melting_face:

1 Like

The Calliope and Firefly are premiums tho

So what you’re saying is that because the 50kg bomb has 10% less max damage compared to the 250lb gp, it’s okay for the bf109 to get double the payload? The difference in max damage doesn’t even come close to equating to one extra bomb, much less two.

Hah, that’s a good joke. The shermans don’t hold a candle to the panther and tiger. Just because the firefly can penn a panther/tiger, doesn’t mean it’s any where near it’s level. It’s still just a br3 sherman tank.

And XA-38 is an event airplane. Doesn’t really matter when it comes to the balancing. Are they rare compared to the TT and impacts the game balance less? Sure. They shouldn’t be a subject of game balancing? I don’t think so.