Move the D4Y1 to BR2

The D4Y1 is a BR3 attacker aircraft for Japan, and it is currently rather weak for it’s position, especially when looking at how the Xa-38 is on the same rank and the devs have not touched it since they added it. By moving this aircraft down to BR2, it will fit balance better and give BR2 Japan a decent attacker.

In terms of armament, this plane has a pair of 7.7mm machine guns in the nose and a rear machine gun in the same caliber, of which do laughably little damage to enemy aircraft. The main selling point of this plane is the large 500kg bomb it can carry, and while very powerful, it’s the same size as what BR2 attackers already have (more on that later).

The flight performance of the D4Y1, like most Japanese planes, is slightly ahead of other aircraft in terms of turn speed at around 14 seconds compared to 17-19 seconds, which is a definite advantage. Worth mentioning as well is that on the majority of Japan’s maps except for 2, where carrier takeoff is forced, this plane takes quite a while to get to takeoff and get to the battlefield, which hinders it’s usefulness in competitive lobbies where every second counts compared to most American planes which don’t have to deal with that.

However, the aspect that people almost always seem to glance over in balance talks is the extreme fragility of Japanese planes, and this is no exception. There are no armor plates on the plane at all and all the fuel tanks are not self sealing, so even just a few rifle caliber rounds can inflict heavy damage or catch your plane on fire depending on where they hit. Most other planes even in BR1 have one of or both features, which greatly increases their survival.

Now comparing the D4Y1 to the Stuka R2 and Dauntless, of which are BR2, we see that this wouldn’t really be that powerful in comparison if lowered to the same BR. By looking at the bullet points below, it can be seen that the D4Y1 is really just a more fragile but more maneuverable Stuka R2, while the Dauntless has a much better armament in exchange for a worse turn speed.

D4Y1

- 2x rifle caliber main guns + 1 rifle caliber rear MG
- 1x 500kg bomb
- 14 second turn time
- 550 Kph max speed
- Forced carrier takeoff in Pacific maps
- No armor or self sealing fuel tanks

Stuka R2

- 2x rifle caliber main guns + 1 rifle caliber rear MG
- 1x 500kg bomb
~17 second turn speed
- Has some armor, but no self sealing fuel tanks
- No forced carrier takeoff
- 380 Kph max speed

Dauntless

- 440 Kph max speed
- 2x Heavy machine guns and 2x rifle caliber main guns + 2x rifle caliber rear MGs
- 1x 1000lb bomb + 2x 100lb bombs (equivalent of 500kg and 50kg bombs)
- Has decent armor and self sealing fuel tanks
- slightly under 19 second turn time
- Forced carrier takeoff in Pacific maps

So, with all of this information, I think that moving the D4Y1 to BR2 won’t be a problem for balance. With Japan getting the D4Y1 on BR2, it will allow for a more versatile attacker compared to the B5N2 to be used.

Should the D4Y1 be moved to BR2?
  • Yes
  • No
0 voters
4 Likes

Can I see a in game picture of the plane you’re talking about?

Added a picture to the main post, here’s another as well.

Remove forced carrier takeoff and Japans air power will improve marginally.

4 Likes

How so if the americans also have to do it?

I wasn’t speaking specifically for Japan.

Then what are you talking about if you say it would marginally improve Japan’s air power?

i said what i said… allies are already strong but it would be even more improved if they didnt have forced take off… i didnt mean only japan should get their carrier spawns in the air.

Ok, so here’s how I interpreted what you said:

In first post: Japan would gain a slight advantage to the US if both didn’t have forced carrier take off.

I originally thought you were saying that Japan would be more advantaged than the Allies if both started off in the air

1 Like

Yeah i realized how it sounded… im more so saying that it would put them on par with US air power and that it would be good if they removed forced carrier takeoff

Yep it’s much closer to BR2 Ju-87 R-2 than to its BR3 “counterparts”:

1 Like

2 br already has its counterpart, B5N2.

And how exactly is the B5N2 a counterpart for the Ju87 R2 or Dauntless? The absolutely only thing it has over them is turn speed, but that doesn’t really matter when it has no forward armament to speak of. The bombs are powerful but not enough to say it’s a good plane, it could honestly be moved to BR1.

1 Like

of course, it’s weaker in terms of armament, but it flies great)

As for me, whether you have 2 7mm machine guns or not makes 0 difference, there is no adequate damage and the weapon is purely just in case.,
so there is no difference from r2, they are both bad for aerial combat)