Why i am against PPSh nerf

I would say buff ALL guns in the game by reducing dispersion heavily. Then increase recoil universally, trying to maintain historical accuracy but also consider balance (for example PPSh irl is extremely controllable, but maybe would need higher recoil for gameplay balance).

This means your bullets will go where you aim. Recoil control will be a skill and will force people to consider crouching/prone/bracing to counter higher recoil.

1 Like

Who even said PPSH box is getting fixed? Haven’t seen such announcement.

1 Like

Well I feel like that would make most SMGs a little too overpowered when compared to Rifles.

1 Like

This is the current situation of BR5:

The Soviets had better assault rifles and aircrafts, and the Germans have better automatic rifles, machine guns and tanks.

And this is the 2nd most balanced version for eastern front BR5 since the merge. The most balanced version is after fedorov been buffed to 13.9 before fg42-2 buffed to 15.3.

Euthy confirmed it here

Well, all rifles definitely deserve a dispersion buff, nothing is more frustrating than a long range gun being limited in accuracy.

3 Likes

ppsh 41 box dispersion: 0.21
mkb42 dispersion: 0.53

an SMG should not be over 2x as accurate as an assault rifle, this thread is full of insane people, it needs nerfed, you dont buff every SMG to be more accurate than ARs

12 Likes

That’s what I’m saying!

I would be okay with this.

But this is currently arguing against a fix not based on how the game is working, but how you wished the game was working, which isn’t really part of the discussion…?

Make a new post suggesting this idea, I’d support it, but leaving the PPSh-41 as is in the current game enviornment is not an option. You’re not garnering much in the way of support throwing yourself in front of this change, rather the opposite.

Change goals, don’t be in opposition to this change, be in favour of a new system instead.

2 Likes

Their rifle isn’t better, especially against body armor.

Yes. Germany is the only country, that used assault rifles. In the game they have the worst ones

Man, have you seen RD-44? It has no dispersion debuffs

4 Likes

its old, but the ppsh box havent changed anywhere nor stg44 so ttk is still exactly the same.

And since this is just TTK it doesnt take in account the recoil nor dispersion, which both favors ppsh over stg.

Maybe, but that can be balanced by changing damage, damage falloff, velocity, rof, reload, recoil, etc. The key thing I want is for bullets to go where I aim. When I go to the shooting range irl, my bullets don’t miss because of “dispersion” they miss because I aimed poorly. I want guns in Enlisted to do the same.

Also, historically, there is a reason that rifles fell out of favor for automatics; they can always adjust BRs so that only crappy smgs run against bolties/lower semis in addition to the above.

Actually the AS-44 did see service just very little

Well irl, your gun will have dispersion, mainly because your gun has a pretty short barrel. SMG are not for sniping, they are for close quarters combat.

Application - это заявка в плане “подать заявку (на участие)”
They are called ‘gold orders’.

SMG (sub-machine gun), pp - male organ.

Riflemen

Body armor. 100% needs to be removed and made cosmetic only.


In general, as far as I understand, PPSh now has broken dispersion – so it’s not a nerf, it’s a fix.

5 Likes

I don’t think dispersion on ANY semi-auto should be nerfed. It should be buffed to bolty levels imo.

The reload on the SVT is what needs nerfing

1 Like

Correction of obviously broken dispersion is not a nerf, it’s a fix. :man_shrugging:

So I have no clue what are you even talking about.

2 Likes

If it hasn’t been updated for a long time, then it’s fake
And how could PPSh change, they just didn’t notice, so this is fake information from this site

Because I see this as a step back. It’s crabs pulling each other back into the bucket. Right now there are a few standout weapons that should be the baseline for all weapons in their class.

  • SMG: PPSh box dipersion.
  • Semis: SVT38/Breda Carcano post movement dispersion cone reduction speed.
  • LMGs: RD-44 no ads movement dispersion penalty

The reason all those guns are considers BiS is because of their much lower dispersion metrics. All weapons need to be brought in line, not have those few squished down and killed. Them sticking out like a sore thumb keeps people talking about it and shows what good feeling weapons look like.