Tier 3 Casemate Fighting Vehicles down tier?

Suggestions
1

What about having tier 3 casemate vehicles like StuG III be Tier 2? I wonder would the tier 4 vehicles would be OP being down one tier tho?

3 Likes
2

It really depends. The 85mm and long 75, no matter how limited in use they are on a casemate vehicle, don’t really belong at BR3 at all. Not until BR3 stops seeing BR2.

But I do agree, the StuG and marder should both be dropped down a BR, especially when the Chaffee and Lee/Grant sit at BR2.

5 Likes
3

a simple question how easily they kill br1 from all sides, front-back-left-right, at any angle
b how easily can br 1 kill stug marder

c how easily can br3 kill stug marder
d how easily can stug marder kill br3

first if stug marder easily kill br but br1 struggle to kill stug marder
its simple br 1tanks are almost unarmored and armed
yes as it is br 3 can see br 4 but its just not fair on br1
if i am wrong just show me an area on the stug or marder bigger than its own shells a br1 can kill it

4

Seriously? Grant is fun but not OP. Chaffee is a premium and also incredibly weak against german tanks. The germans have so many better tanks in tier 2. No clue what your on about. 76mm marder definitely does not belong in tier 2. You should agree if you think long barreled 75mm is br4+…your logic doesnt logic as both marders are “long barreled” 75 and 76mm

5

yeahh but the grant is a giant tin can, that can be seen from low orbit
the stug and marder are low silhouette with heavy armor
not the same thing

6

Jagdpanzer IV L48 is useless im BR4 because it has 60mm of armor ( historically not accurate)

Jagdpanzer IV L70 is pointless in BR5 because Panther is BR4, and Tiger II is the much better coice.

I can understand that people fear Jagdpanzer IV L70 being a BR4 vehicle, but L48? It should get its 80mm of armor so that Germany has its own Jumbo tank at BR4 - worse gun than average, better armor than average.

2 Likes