Disclaimer, that I am a 7 day old Enlisted player, a F2P player and thus this is only my observation of the game up until now. TL;DR down below.
The Grind - Not Problem, Gameplay Fun
The grind is not a problem in Enlisted? Yes, because the gameplay is fun. The maps are awesome, the guns feel great, the mechanics of squad management is unique and having AI is pretty cool compared to other FPS games out there. The different classes are fun in each way, there is a lot of flexibility and strategy going on for an FPS game. All in all, the gameplay in itself as a whole is very fun.
Therefor, the grind is not a problem, if a gameplay is fun. If the grind is fun, then it’s not a grind, because it’s not dull or obnoxious.
The Problem - The Reward System, Lack of Resources & Flexibility
Main reason why I don’t want to play Enlisted are the lack of certain resources (the green cards - that let you change the upgrade selections tree & the bronze cards, that let you upgrade your soldier and guns). Enlisted created this great squad management system where you can optimize squad to your liking (in terms of squad members, guns, etc.) But, at the same time, Enlisted cuts you out of flexibility and verity of squads management system, which contradicts itself.
Story Time #1
E.g. I have a Flamethrower squad and I want to try if it’s better to have:
- 2 engineers + 1 AT Gunner or
- 2 engineer + 1 Machine Gunner or
- 1 engineer + 2 Assaulters or etc.
But, because I don’t have the green order change card (whatever its name is) I have to permanently decide without even trying in battle on what to choose - forever and ever! It hurts the players and fun, because they can’t try out different tactics and try out different members in their squad. The whole squad management system crumbles. I don’t want to watch someone’s YouTube videos to determine which one is better for my uses, I want to test it out for myself and I can’t do that! At least give us a 1 free change or an option to reset the whole upgrade tree, but at the cost of squad level going to 0. Just give us more options to change and tweak things to our liking! Please do something about this. I can’t be the only one that hates they can’t tweak and change their squads over and over to find what really works for them. This is, beside the gameplay, where the Enlisted shines!
Story Time #2
E.g. I am playing the Normandy, and I am about to reach level 13. After level 13 (after unlocking mortarman squad), there is really no reason for me to keep playing the Normandy. I have all my squads to desired level and perks, I have the guns I need, I have the different squads, so why should I keep going over and over again on the same maps, same faction, same this, same that, same campaign, etc. if the amount of XP needed to get to a new level just keeps going up Up UP without the rewards following.
TL;DR
At the end of the day, I guess you have to options:
- Decrease the grind, but keep the same rewards
- Keep the grind, but increase the rewards
The second options is better I think, because the company can keep the precious monetization ($$$) for those people who just don’t want to grind or enjoy having a wider experience (e.g. more squads in battle), but at the same time F2P players can get much more rewards for that hard but satisfying i.e. “worth it” grind. The grind is not a problem, because the gameplay is fun. But, the reward system is very scarce with given resources for the grind, making the grind just not worth it terms of resources after some point.
Again, just my 7 day old opinion, so not really sure what is best for the game, but wanted to point out that grind is not a problem due to gameplay being fun. But, the grind is just not worth it due to lack of rewards I get at the end of it. All the best.