M8 scott and M10 tank is good tank

agreed.

in an ucpoming thread that i was making about reworks i had in mind to suggest them.

just to make it clear :slight_smile:

i hope so.

i would like perhaps cosmetics roofs made out of wood or simply flags that covers the whole top. but i do not like that stops bullet. and therefore i wouldn’t put a plus one as you might to see the crew inside and lead to a massive advantage.

yes, but there are a few maps where halfrakcs can be devastating and go where tanks would struggle.

that’s what i meant.

and therefore picking out the crew it’s somewhat easier ( if you are in elevated positions ) and much practical ( as should be )

i mean, the panther exist because of the jumbo ( as developer stated ) so…

it ain’t me that you have to look after.

i despite both the jumbo and the panther for that regard because players with m5s and pumas are surely gonna love those. and therefore leave a friendly and positive review about the first expeirence ( i don’t bloody blain them )

still, from a technical aspect, the panther is much slower in this game compared to wt ( to obvious reasons i suppose ) and as the jumbo get affected by small cliffs and holes, the same can happen for panthers.

No m8. I ain’t blaming anyone here. It’s just a game. Like you said it’s developers decision.

Correct. Last night M8 Scott somehow managed to pen my front armour on Panther A after 3rd shot. 3 shots he bounced 4th one managed to get in and kill 3 crew members. Was gobsmacked tbh. Bad positioning and he was on higher ground.
It’s just that Panther A will have in most situations an upper hand against Jumbo.

1 Like

I play both sides and 100% agree with OP.

Open top roofed tanks are pretty annoying it means you lose crew very fast bots aggro on machine gunners very fast and players will snipe you. Then you are relegated to playing with just driver and main gunner.

I see no reason why we couldn’t get a closed top version for both tanks.

This isn’t a thread about Jumbo or tank balance FFS. Stop trying to start debates/arguments.

He’s also not comparing it to Panthers etc.

Just stating the fact that having an open top tank is a disadvantage. If historically there were roofed versions it would be great to have those instead.

1 Like

i mean, it kinda got derailed a litte ( if can follow a conversation ).

it was meant to @HLiqe

and that’s why i stepped in because it’s a BAD idea.

first of all, you can’t even read.
and this is quite sad.
image

fucking timetraveler?

get outta here.

second, there is no need for such buff.

disavantage or not, those were the main feature of the tank. blame who back in the days designed such vehicle being open top. not the devs that somewhat recreated the vehicle.

for the same reasons, those are not present.

i wonder why.

I’m not starting a debate a thon with you. It’s a waste of my time and a lost cause from reading some of your previous posts.

Second. I’m not one of those who cares that much about historical accuracy etc as there is enough inaccuracies in this game already.

What I care about is in-game fun and usability.

From a fun perspective - It’s not fun to constantly lose your crew because you are force switched into a vacant seat in an open top tank.

Usability - After losing most of your crew be forced to play driving around in gunner mode which is a very zoomed in. If there is a variant of this vehicle that does have a roof I would be all for getting that version instead of these version.

as an american player my self, i just disagree with everything you just said.

because if you complain about losing crew, sounds like someone is making a mistake.

and therefore you should not receive a roof top so that the majority can charge without have to worry ( like 80% of the m8s users do ) that’s why you should play tactically and guess what, you don’t end up losing crew mates. and then, what next? rooftops for bikes as well?

1 Like

Lol, what a stupid argument. You lose crew because it’s an open top tank no matter if your really far away you will still get sniped.

I’ve read enough of your posts that I’m tired of seeing you argue or create arguments with people over petty reasons.

Congrats. Your the first person I’ve added to my ignore list.

1 Like

you don’t see me complaining about loosing crew though.

bye bye.

i feel honored i suppose.

although, don’t complain about the others if you don’t know how to play or can’t figure out a way on your own.

1 Like