Indian/Gurkha Squads?

we need equality for everyone…

here are some suggestions for allied squads

idk if premium moroccan squad counts for this one…

also there are several minor massacres by US, but it is really hard to select one representative squad from them.

war crimes are war crimes.

i want to hear strategic aspect of mass raping

thanks

@Naohmcete

I think your arguments are not worth responding to and are tantamount to warcrime denial.

@robihr,

I think your arguments are rather weak.

Lest start with your point about equality, this is frankly a bad reason for including this squad and makes you sound a bit childish. ‘Someone else has it’ is not an argument (unless your talking about game balance). Besides, the SS squad should bot have been added either, NKVD is also highly questionable. ‘Equality’ in this context is retarted. Why add equality when they could just add other more interesting squads for Japanese? Why add the most evil japanese soldiers?
Also just a smal sidenote, i dont now to much about the specific NKVD squads, but these guys were also just militairy police units, every army has them. The NKVD did horrible things, but also just normal militairy police stuf. So the in game squad might not have been involved with to many crimes while with 731 we now pretty fucking well that they got involved in major crimes. So, their is a qualitative difference when comparing these units. (Although, as said, I dont know ghe specifics about the depicted NKVD squads, they might be horrible too, but i hope you understand my point regardless)

The point about rape does not work on any level and is by far the weakest argument. To compare horror units which purpose was to do to cruel tests on humans to Morocan rape is just dumb. Look rape is horrible, but everyone did this, Japs, Germans, Soviets. To compare this to the horror of Japanese human testing? the Soviets, Canadians and US did not go out of their way to do such horrible things. One is soldiers misbehaving and negligent leadership, (not a strategy as you called it). The other is a Japanese government purposely sending out soldiers to force people into brutal cruel human tests. There is a BIG fucking difference between those two things. So, no warcrimes are not just warcrimes in this case.

To explain in very very simple terms. There is a significant difference between depicting a squad that have done some bad things while in a long war, and a squads which main purpose was to do bad things for some fucked up ideological or scientific reason.

So, stop pretending everyone is on the same level here.

PS. If you want to find actually hypocrisy of the allies;
I actually had to do research into the topic of victors peace at Neurenburg once. I believe I stil have some papers laying around. If you want I could share the title with you so you could look it up. In summary, there were cases of hypocrazy, stuf like Germany getting punished for unrestricted submarine warfare, eventhough the US pretty much did the same thing against the Japanese.

1 Like

okey, with all we shared it’s clear you have issues ^^

it was more sarcasm, rather than actual argument. if we are going to have war criminals in the game, then we shouldnt discriminate by nation.

hey war crimes are terrible, but everyone did this… :+1:

oh silly soldiers misbehaving…

"In S. Andrea, the Moroccans raped 30 women and two men; in Vallemaio two sisters had to satisfy a platoon of 200 goumiers; 300 of these, on the other hand, abused a sixty-year-old. In Esperia, 700 women were raped out of a population of 2,500 inhabitants, with 400 complaints presented. Even the parish priest, Don Alberto Terrilli, in an attempt to defend two girls, was tied to a tree and raped for a whole night. He died two days later from internal lacerations reported. In Pico, a girl was crucified with her sister. After the gang violence, she will be killed. Polleca reached the pinnacle of bestiality. Luciano Garibaldi writes that from the Moroccan departments of the gen. Guillaume girls and old women were raped; the men who reacted were sodomized, shot dead, emasculated or impaled alive. A testimony, from a report of the time, describes their typical modality: “The Moroccan soldiers who had knocked on the door and which was not opened, knocked down the door itself, hit the fortress with the butt of the musket to the head making it fall to the ground unconscious, then she was carried about 30 meters from the house and raped while her father, by other soldiers, was dragged, beaten and tied to a tree. The terrified bystanders could not bring any help to the girl and the parent as a soldier remained on guard with a musket aimed at them.”

Given the involvement of non-commissioned officers and white officers, some of them Italian-speaking as Corsican, not present in the Goumier troop departments, it can be said that the rapists nestled in all four divisions of the CEF. Perhaps also for this reason, the French officers did not respond to any solicitation from the victims and watched impassively at the work of their men. As the testimonies report, when civilians showed up to report the violence, the officers shrugged their shoulders and dismissed them with a smirk.
— Baris Tommaso

there is absolutely no difference when large parts of certain squads committed war crimes under explicit or implicit approval of their officers/generals. we are not talking about 2-3 soldiers going out and raping few civilians. we are talking about systematic killings and rapings that you downplay cause other side was worse. NKVD killed ~100k prisoners in few weeks after barbarossa started. moroccans raped 2000-12000 women and men while killing many of them in gruesome way.

to be clear i am against all of the squads with war crime history in the game, but if we are going to have them, then at least they need to be consistent and include them from every nation.

Why?

People like you are the reason this game is stale and boring.

Refusing content that makes sense while supporting all these stupid high rank fairytale guns that are dragging us into the postwar era.

2 Likes

The most shitty post of Enlisted Forum in 2025

love what canadians done to the jerries. They just let jerries paid for what they done, and being far from concluding the debt.
I believe that what Allies had done in Germany and Japan is far from enough–Morgenthau’s plan could came in handy, while the result of not being enough is YOU

1 Like

animals…

Says the guy who wants some of the most horrible soldiers in game lol :joy:

Homies i just wanted some damm Indians and Nepalese squads in the game what is all this?

2 Likes

Welcome to the forum my friend where the most important discussions are happening how to improve the game:
red-alert3-tim-curry

we have already some of them already, why not more? :3

my honest apologizes,your idea is amazing

Il explain it one last time:

  1. Just because they made a mistake somewhere else does not mean they should do it again. Why do you even want to play as a warcrime unit wtf

  2. The SS and NKVD squads had at least been in combat. This unit was just for the horror show.

  3. There is a qualatative difference between some of the comparisons made by your line of arguments.

Look, i might be a bit to aggressive in my arguments, this is because I actually had to study some of this shit, so just one last point from a purely tactical angle;
I usually agree with you on a lot of point because we both like the Jap faction and both want it to get more love. Now, how do you think we’re getting across to the devs when the Japanese players are asking for warcrime units? Besides, there are way more interesting squads to add for japs.

fr

And I’ll genuinely explain it to you bluntly: Japan, if you’re going to block one, delete the faction itself. More than 90% of the squadrons in the game already have one or two incidents against human rights, cruelty, war crimes, etc.

well…

“we do” have them for all nations.

germany have lots of SS squads, and, for certain, ( that i can think of ) the Heer 90 light infantry did committed war crimes.

in the us, not much is documented beside the 45th ( which we don’t have ) and the marines ( which we do have ) and allegedly, some of them took skulls from corpses.

as for japan… well, i don’t know much about them. but… yeah. it was still ww2 japan we’re talking about.

and, from a certain point of view, we do still kill civilians in the game as well :sweat_smile:

but this thread has gone ape poo-doo.

and completely irrelevant to the thread at hand.

Gurkhas should absolutely be in enlisted.

anyway.

Naohmcete not being a weeaboo for 5 seconds, impossible challenge.

1 Like

with this i agree.

1 Like