The ZH-29 and the Gewehr 43 are both BR4 and are good semi auto rifle but. The ZH-29 does 15.8 damage, Gewehr 43 does 15.3 if fully upgrade. while the Breda pg carcano (event not gold order) does 13.6 same damage as Armaguerra mod 36. The Breda pg carcano should be bump down to BR3 because it has a lower damage and Germany only two semi auto rifle that is Gewehr 41does 14.4 damage and VG-15 does 9.6 damage. (This is my opinion but if playing BR4 with Breda pg carcano you could be bump up to BR5 and the FG42 1 and mark 2 outclass the Breda PG carcano by it full auto and and higher damage)
No.
7 Likes
do keep in mind that the carcano 25 rounds dealing enough damage to down someone
1 Like
Its 20 rounds, but the recoil is the same as the VG1-5 so like lmfao, the OP is crazy suggesting it should be downtiered
The correct solution is advocating for a separate BR3 + BR4 tier, and make BR5 standalone
6 Likes
or just have it be plus 1 minus 1 mm
2 Likes
Nope, I believe BR4 and BR5 should be separate because BR4 weapons like the G43, SVT-40, Johnson Rifle, are ridiculously unviable in a BR5 meta with FG42s and AVTs
Breda PG (Carcano) is one of the very best semi-auto only rifle in this game, that thing is like way better than any of the Tech Tree semi-auto at BR IV (like Johnson, Type 4, SVT40 and Gewehr 43) there is no way that thing goes to BR3.
1 Like
I wrote this to get other people opinion and see what they’re thought on this weapon.
1 Like
Bro want breda Pg carcano the best Italian semi auto that can 2 tap someone to be low br this is one of those crazy suggestions ngl
nah dude, bad idea, you put the breda pg in BR3 then suddenly the other factions want the farquhar hill or the SVT40 drum in br3, its a slippery slope
2 Likes
Yeah, that thing together with the Mondragon are worthy of sitting in BR4 - unlike most other semi autos.
The Breda has no recoil and is super accurate - if you would put FG42s on semi auto the Breda would perform better.
Honestly, I can see myself using it over an MKB.
Is a to good gun for BR3
well it would be fun to have breda pg carcano on br3… just cause it would be ridiculously OP weapon with which you could farm BR1 and BR2.
2 Likes
Yeah but the Breda pg carcano is a old event weapon and not every one is going to have it also this could be a exclusive weapon to player who played the game before the merged update happen.
So you want veterans steamrolling new people with worse equipment?
2 Likes
yea there really is no good reason for it to be br3 tbh 20round semi that 2 tap people? nah too much for low br
You’re right it should stay in BR4 because it 20 round mag and fast reload it’s basically a FG42 but semi auto, I guess I was wrong of thinking to bring it to BR3.
it has a hidden 0.25 recoil multiplier making its recoil the exact same as the vg1-5 too
It’s an excellent semi-automatic rifle
But it’s still not a fully automatic rifle
So he can only stay in the high-end field gathering dust
Unless you want to see a group of people using this thing to wreak havoc in low-level fields (I want to do that)