I think you’re missing the point. I’m not disagreeing with you, I’m just saying the system we implemented might just be good enough. Trust me, I don’t want to see PPShs in German hands any more than you do (dear god DF, just don’t put it in the German tech tree).
Enlisted is just in a fragile state right now. Lots of players are still feeling mixed about the new major changes, so I think the devs want to ensure the survival of the game before tinkering with the matchmaking system.
Think of it this way, let’s say the update works out great and enlisted sees a surge in growth. At that point, the soft rule should be good enough because there’s enough total players to put players in the correct time period for their gear.
For example, there’s enough players with early war Soviet gear to match up, that you can equip and IS-2 and not have to worry about getting put in an early war map. This will definitely be the case because I expect there to be more early war players overall than late war players.
Maybe once in like 30+ games you bring your IS-2 to Moscow, and at that point, you still reserve the right to quit. That’s a pretty good solution for a tricky problem.
Basically, the more players there are, the more effective the soft rule is. Who knows, maybe your IS-2 will never see Moscow even after hundreds of games. I think we just need to see how the system plays out.
This I do have to respectfully disagree with, because calling Enlisted a fantasy world is a stretch. Everything in the game is still within the time period of WW2. The IS-2 didn’t fight in Moscow, but it was in WW2.
If the Americans had M16 prototypes, AH-1 attack choppers, and M42 Pattons storming the beaches of Normandy, then that would be a nonsense fantasy world and I would definitely find that extremely immersion breaking.
But I don’t know, in my opinion, I think it’s cool to have those ahistorical matches every once in a while. I’m more concerned whether or not I’ll be matched against proper equipment. I, personally, could live with a King Tiger in Moscow as long as I have something that can actually fight it.